Connect with us

Judiciary

Court fixes June 30 for judgment in Melaye’s suit against Infections Disease Bill

Published

on

Court fixes June 30 for judgment in Melaye’s suit against Infections Disease Bill

The Federal High Court, Abuja, on Monday, fixed June 30 to deliver judgment in the suit filed by Dino Melaye challenging the passage of the Infectious Diseases Bill


Justice Ijeoma Ojukwu fixed the date after taking arguments from parties in the case.

The bill, which is sponsored by the Speaker of the House of Representatives, Femi Gbajabiamila and two other lawmakers – Pascal Obi and Tanko Sununu- seeks to empower the Federal Government to convert any property in the country, including private property, to isolation centres.

The bill also seeks to empower the government to, upon mere suspicion that a person is infected with an infectious disease, arrest and detain the person for as long as necessary, among others.

The News Agency of Nigeria reports that Melaye had, on May 5, claimed that the provisions of the Bill violate his fundamental rights, among which are rights to the dignity of person, personal liberty, right to private and family life, right to freedom of movement and right to own immovable property in Nigeria.

While the clerk of the National Assembly is the 1st respondent, the Clerk of the House of Representatives, Speaker of the House of Representatives, Attorney General of the Federal (AGF) and the Inspector General of Police (IGP) are 2nd, 3rd, 4th and 5th respondents respectively in the suit.

Justice Ojukwu had, on June 1, adjourned the matter until June 15 while advising parties to restrain themselves from actions that could jeopardise the suit.

Earlier, Counsel to Melaye, Nkem Okoro told the court that the matter was for continuation of hearing.
Okoro urged the court to grant all the reliefs sought by his client in the application.

However, Kayode Ajulo, Counsel to the Speaker of House of Representatives, Femi Gbajabiamila; lawyer to the AGF, M.L. Shiru and Kehinde Oluwole, who represented IGP, urged the court to strike out the matter for lack of merit.

They argued that a bill, which was yet to become a law, could not have infringed on the plaintiff’s fundamental rights.

In her argument, Shiru, who represented the AGF, stated that the country’s constitution provided for separation of powers among the three organs of government.

“And in explaining this doctrine of separation of powers my lord, we refer the honourable court to the case of AGF and Guardian Newspapers.

The citation are supplied in our preliminary objection my lord,” she said.

According to her, in view of the principle of separation of powers as applicable, we are quite aware that the honourable court can interfere in legislative processes when there is only a defiance from the provisions of the constitution.

“However, this power can only be exercised in respect of enacted laws and not legislative bills and we urge your lordship to uphold our submissions in the preliminary objection and decline to grant the reliefs of the applicant,” she remarked.

She stressed that the National Assembly had the powers to make and amend laws as provided by the constitution.

The lawyer said although Melaye had laid emphasises on Sections 6, 29, 30 and 47 of the proposed bill, she urged the court to “dismiss all the reliefs sought by the applicant on the provisions of the bill as vexatious and annoying.”

According to her, the application falls short of fundamental rights application.

“The applicant has not proved that the bill infringe on his fundamental rights.

“A bill is not a law yet and if it is not a law, how can it infringe on his right.

“Therefore, application of the applicant should be discountenance by the court,” Shiru said.

The lawyer asked the court to also award a cost against the applicant (Melaye) for bringing such application before the court.

Edited By: Joe Idika/Sadiya Hamza (NAN)

Taiye Agbaje: is a graduate and a professionally trained journalist, with experience in national news reporting/editing and verification at the News Agency of Nigeria. NNN is a Nigerian online news portal that publishes breaking news in Nigeria, and across the world. Our journalists are honest, fair, accurate, thorough and courageous in gathering, reporting and interpreting news in the best interest of the public, because truth is the cornerstone of journalism and they strive diligently to ascertain the truth in every news report. Contact: editor[at]nnn.com.ng

Military allays fear over alleged Al-Qaeda, ISIS inroad to Nigeria NCPC partners CAN, JNI to end Southern Kaduna killings COVID-19: PTF approves gradual reopening of international flights LASG calls for synergy among security agencies COVID-19: Kogi Govt fumigates schools ahead of resumption on Aug. 10 Gov Ikpeazu calls for Federal Secretariat in Abia Asaba Airport to resume operation soon – Delta SSG APC appoints acting state chairman in Akwa Ibom NCC tasks ICT reporters to work in synergy with Commission COVID-19: Coy launches `BackToWork’ safety module for businesses, organisations Boat mishap claims 9 lives in Sokoto   Bayelsa host communities urge FG, Shell to ignore alleged 21 days ultimatum Nasarawa Govt. vows to fish out killers of veteran journalist COVID-19: BEDC donates 100 motoriised hand washing machines to states, others Potato prices crash in Kano Gov. Oyetola launches N100m post COVID-19 Economic Intervention Programme Plateau varsity management, staff undergo COVID-19 test NELMCO saves FG N91bn from PHCN liabilities – MD Minister commends Buhari for support on fight against rape, violence against women Flood: NEMA stakeholders evacuate refuse on Jos waterways Court awards N1m damages against EKEDC for disconnecting consumer over former occupant’s unpaid bills Mobile Payment Operators elect Alabraba as new association chairman We’ll support nutritional activities in Nasarawa – Assembly Speaker Shippers Council donates hospital equipment, relief materials to hospital, orphanage in Jos Man to die by hanging for killing fellow herdsman in Ekiti School resumption: Zamfara Govt. begins fumigation of 193 secondary schools Budgetary pressure: Capital market stakeholders seek alternative funding for infrastructure development I-G Adamu threatens to N10bn damages suit against Sahara Reporters if… Nigeria stock market advances by N26bn Insecurity: Buhari calls for synergy among security agencies heads Gov Sule promises justice for family of 3-month-old baby raped in Nasarawa Troops deactivate 25 illegal refineries, impound 342,000 ltrs of AGO in South-South COVID-19: CACOVID targets 10m people with palliatives worth N23bn PenCom initiates process to review 2014 Pension Reform Act North West farmers back to work amid troops operations –DHQ AFAN wants FG to establish commodity board to mop-up excess farm produce Kwara govt. pledges to reposition Aviation College, inaugurates visitation panel Ekiti court dissolves 11-year-old marriage on grounds of threats to life, others Enugu state community laments lack of government presence Lagos, stakeholders seek sustained implementation of breastfeeding policy Gender activist advocates enforcement of policies protecting girls, women’s rights Draft document on protecting telecoms infrastructure awaits presidential assent — Pantami Gov. Oyetola inaugurates committee against gender violence Group seeks meritocracy for appointment of UI VC C’River water board dismisses 6 for non performance Taraba govt. sensitises citizens on exclusive breastfeeding INEC to clear materials for previous elections Australia opens first face mask testing facility Delta Govt to invoke laws against illegal structures COVID-19: WHO sends 40 health experts to South Africa