Connect with us

Judiciary

Court of Appeal sets aside Osun tribunal Judgment, affirms Oyetola as Osun Governor

Published

on

 

Judgment

In a majority judgment of four-to-one, delivered by the Chairman of the five-man panel, Justice Jumai Hannatu-Sankey upturned the tribunal judgment which returned Sen. Ademola Adeleke as the winner of the election.

Sankey in a four- to-one judgment, declared that the decision of the tribunal which sacked Oyetola as governor was not valid and consequently set aside the entire proceedings of the tribunal.

The appellate court nullified the majority judgment of the tribunal delivered by Peter Obiora, on the grounds that he relied on the evidence of two witnesses which he did not observe.

Justice Sankey noted that the Court of Appeal ordinarily having set aside the entire proceedings of the tribunal, ought to order a re-trial of the case.

However, she said, the appellate court could not order a re-trial because the 180 days provided by the law for election petition had elapsed.

Meanwhile, Justice George Mbaba in a dissenting judgment, dismissed the appeal and upheld the decision of the tribunal.

Justice Mbaba held that Justice Obiora who did not participate in the proceedings of February 6, 2019 was contentious and enough reason to nullify the appeal.

He added that all the members of the panel ought to have been on seat to sign the proceedings of Feb.6, 2019 and subsequently disagreed with the judgment of the other four members.

Mbaba further noted that the issue of sabotage cannot be ruled out as the records were transmitted by court’s registrar.

He consequently dismissed the appeal and upheld the majority decision of the tribunal which sacked Oyetola and returned Adeleke as Governor.

Mbaba however awarded cost of N200k against Oyetola.

Another appeal filed by the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) was also upheld by the majority of four to one panel.

Again, in his dissenting judgment, Justice Mbaba came down heavily on the electoral umpire,INEC for its failure to live up to expectation in the conduct of the election.

He held that INEC which did not call any witness at the tribunal or tendered any document surprising came to the Appeal Court to file an appeal.

He said the electoral electoral umpire was wrong for saying that Adeleke and PDP cannot challenge the September 27, rerun election on the grounds that they had waived their rights by participating in the said election.

According to Mbaba, no serious party would boycott any rerun election when a final declaration had not been made.

He said INEC acted dubiously in the rerun election.

“INEC acted dubiously in the way it handled the rerun election, INEC should not have been put in the dock if it has done the right thing at the rerun election.

“ When INEC was in the dock it shied away without filing any argument”, Mbaba said.

On the cancellation of results in 17 polling units, Justice Mbaba held that the cancellation was deliberate because INEC returning Officer has no power to do the cancellation.

“It is the presiding Officer that has the power to cancel results if need be,’’ he said.

Other members of the panel were justices Abubakar Yahaya, Isaiah Akeju and Bitrus Sanga.

NAN reports that the tribunal had in its judgment on March 22, voided Oyetola’s election and ordered INEC to withdraw his Certificate of Return while at the same time ordered INEC to issue a fresh Certificate of Return to Adeleke.

However, Oyetola, who contested the last governorship election on the platform of the APC, faulted the majority judgment delivered by Justices Obiora and Anyinla Gbolagunte.

The governor in his 39-ground Notice of Appeal filed on March 26, by his team of lawyers, led by Wole Olanipekun, SAN, claimed that the judgment was “perverse, replete with contradictions and not supported by evidence led by the petitioners”.

He therefore asked the appellate court to uphold his appeal, set aside the majority judgment and dismiss the Oct. 16, 2018 petition by PDP and Adeleke.

The governor said his complaint, in the appeal, was against the entire majority judgment, except where the tribunal held that it lacked jurisdiction to set aside INEC Guidelines; that the allegation of over voting was not proved; that the petitioners did not prove voided votes and other parts of the judgment where the tribunal agreed with their arguments.

Oyetola is contending, in his first ground of appeal, that the entire majority judgment was a nullity, because it was written and delivered by Justice Obiora “who did not participate in all the proceedings of the tribunal and who was not present when all the witnesses gave evidence.”

He noted that Justice Obiora was absent on Feb. 6, when the respondents witnesses Ayoola Soji and Oladejo Kazeem – testified and tendered exhibits, which the tribunal admitted in evidence.

The appellant argued that, having not attended the tribunal’s siting on Feb. 6, Justice Obiora could not have seen the two witnesses and was unable to examine their demeanour, as required, and therefore, unlawful for the judge to have authored a judgment in which he reviewed the evidence given by the witnesses.

He said: “The writing of and or the participation of the honourable justice P. C. Obiora in the writing of the judgment of the lower tribunal of March 22, and delivery of same, vitiates the entire judgment.”

Oyetola also argued that the tribunal, in its majority judgment, erred in law and acted without jurisdiction when it accepted the petitioners’ complained of non compliance with the provisions of Electoral Act in relation to the Sept. 22, 2018 governorship election in Osun and on that basis proceeded to nullify the victory of Oyetola and APC.

It was equally the appellant’s contention that the tribunal acted without jurisdiction by basing its decision to uphold the petition and set aside the return of the appellants on the basis of allegation of non-compliance with the Electoral Act, in relation to the Sept. 22 governorship election.

edited by Sadiya Hamza

Aderogba George: is a graduate and a professionally trained journalist, with experience in national news reporting/editing and verification at the News Agency of Nigeria. NNN is a Nigerian online news portal that publishes breaking news in Nigeria, and across the world. Our journalists are honest, fair, accurate, thorough and courageous in gathering, reporting and interpreting news in the best interest of the public, because truth is the cornerstone of journalism and they strive diligently to ascertain the truth in every news report. Contact: editor[at]nnn.com.ng

Contact US: editor @nnn.com.ng, nnnnews247 @gmail.com

Australia suspends extradition agreement with Hong Kong amid new law Chinese mainland reports 9 new confirmed COVID-19 cases, all imported United States lawmakers blast Trump’s decision to formally withdraw WHO Time running out for Libya, UN chief warns Security Council Arsonists in Slovenia torch wooden statue of Melania Trump Cholera outbreak kills 12 in S. Camerounian village EU grants Rwanda 10m euros for private sector dev’t, job creation UN, Somali opposition parties laud planned regional unity meeting COVID-19: UN to re-release Bob Marley’s One Love to support affected children Serbian interior minister describes violent protests as coup attempt Second UN Security Council resolution on Syrian aid fails Transcripts reveal George Floyd said ‘I can’t breathe’ more than 20 times Ivory Coast’s prime minister has died at 61 Unaudited results: NSE warns investors on shares of 13 firms Abia govt commences accelerated nutrition campaign More pilot free trade zone reforms experience to be spread across China COVID-19: Only Private schools that meet laid down protocol will resume – Ekiti Govt. Access Bank to acquire 100% stake in Zambian Bank Nigeria COVID-19 cases hits 30,249 with 460 Wednesday Correctional service empowers ex-offenders with working tools  Barca’s Pique cycled to derby match with Espanyol Golf’s Ryder Cup, Presidents Cup fall victims of coronavirus also Suarez scores as Barca condemn neighbours Espanyol to relegation Salah double keeps Liverpool on track for record points-haul Kwara COVID-19 test centre operational soon – Spokesman · WHO to begin study on origin of COVID-19 COVID-19: Kwara Govt postpones 2020 promotion meeting indefinitely Sokoto Govt awards N11bn flyovers, road contracts Africa records over 500, 000 COVID-19 cases – WHO COVID-19: NCDC to establish test centre in Nasarawa Kebbi incorporates Fulani women into modern dairy production Osun records 11 new coronavirus cases, discharges 4 Zamfara Assembly to enact laws for stiffer penalties for rapists Kwara youth group inaugurates EXCO FG set to develop Agenda 2050, inaugurates Central Working Group Silva shines as Man City thrash Newcastle 5-0 FEC approves N108bn for road projects in 4 states Traditional rulers to attest to recruits’ characters as Ekiti Amotekun commences recruitment Witness in Trump’s impeachment retires from military amid pressure Families’ unity, economic prosperity of Iruland my top priority – Oba Lawal Hushpuppi: NiDCOM boss decries effect on Nation’s image PDP urges FG to prosecute Magu EKSG to fumigate schools ahead of resumption APC ‘II win Nasarawa Assembly bye-election says speaker NHRC, Police partner to tackle rape, other SGBV cases Tambuwal decries politicisation of public service Gov. Tambuwal decries politicisation of public service Airport: FAAN commends passengers’ compliance with COVID-19 prevention protocols  MTN’s ‘What Can We Do Together’ project: Foundation calls for nominations COVID-19: No basis for legal actions against China, says Embassy LASG empowers 300 victims of Abule-Egba pipeline explosion UNILAG VC harps on collaboration to drive innovation, entrepreneurship FG to WAEC: We’ll not reopen our schools in spite of timetable release Alleged financial infractions: Court refuses to grant Okorocha’s plea to stop EFCC, Imo panel from probing him PDP hails Okowa at 61 Rivers APC crisis: Appeal Court fixes July 16 to hear Ogbobula’s suit NSCDC seals 16 illegal private guard companies, arrests 30 staff in A’ Ibom Registration: NAFDAC offers 80 per cent discount to Jigawa entrepreneurs 12 suspected drug traffickers nabbed in 3 months in Niger – NDLEA COVID-19: Bayelsa Govt. moves to enforce compulsory use of face masks 2020 flooding: NEMA strategises ahead, inaugurates committee Kwara Govt pledges to carry along monarchs in policy implementation Abakaliki centre discharges15 fistula patients NSCDC arrests 2 suspected petroleum pipeline vandals in Enugu Africa surpasses half a million COVID-19 cases, WHO says Gov. Zulum inaugurates committee to resolve boundary dispute with neighbours Association hints on possible fuel scarcity over pump price fluctuation Unilorin VC mourns Kwara CoS, Adisa Logun NMDC partners Defence Industries Corporation for local production of arms, ammunition New York City schools will not open completely in September, says Mayor Philippines records new daily high of Covid cases, tally tops 50,000 Iran promise to boost military links with Syria Delta assembly considers bill to prohibit violence against persons Delta assembly considers Bill to prohibit all forms of violence against persons PDP mourns victims of Benue boat mishap Pension: No fixed date to pay 3 months arrears – Military Pensions Board NSE: Market indicators rise further 0.75% Alleged $9.8m fraud: I received the money as gift after I left office, ex-GMD NNPC, Yakubu, tells court Zulum inaugurates committee for medical college, teaching hospital in Borno China allows foreign investors into household service sector COVID-19: Nasarawa technology innovation centre begins production of ventilator Italy wants tougher EU rules on migration to limit COVID-19 risks Hushpuppi: More Nigerians doing positive things than negative abroad – Onyeama Assembly passes Delta N282b revised Appropriation Bill for 2020 Court remands phone repairer for allegedly defrauding customer of N464,500 Men’s clothier Brooks Brothers file for bankruptcy Niger State cautions APC members against anti-party activities Agric: IFAD-VCDP rates Ebonyi best among participating states in Nigeria Ondo Assembly suspends Deputy Speaker as Majority Leader resigns Impeachment saga: Ondo Assembly suspends Deputy Speaker as Majority Leader resigns FG to review size of embassies abroad, TAC scheme – Onyeama Ahmadu Bello Foundation partners NGO to promote peace in Northern states Ebonyi govt to model 2 new institutions to international standard — Officials Banditry: We’ll continue fighting until citizens freely go about their daily activities – CAS FG inaugurates zone 13 police headquarters in Anambra 2019 Batch “B” Stream 2 NYSC corps to pass out July 16 Ogun Govt commences works on flood-prone areas Vote challenging legal system in Israel fails after coalition rift Police arraign man, 21, for alleged break-in, stealing COVID-19 patient gives birth in Ogun Nasarawa State House of Assembly pledges to support sports NAHCON advocates saving scheme for Hajj management COVID-19: Group seeks govt intervention on soaring food prices Adamawa earmarks N4.89bn to construct 1,000 housing units Trade in fake COVID-19 products booming amid demand surge — UNODC OPM offers scholarship to 75 undergraduate, PG students to study overseas Post COVID-19: Kwara will replicate Calabar Carnival model – Commissioner Harvard, MIT sue Trump over ban on foreign students Physician advises parents to show love to physically challenged children Kwara Chief of Staff buried in Ilorin residence Denmark introduces COVID-19 certificate for travelers Counter-terrorism: 1142 soldiers graduate from NASI, Kaduna Gov. Diri commends FG over fire fighting assets deployment 30-year-old man in court for allegedly sexually molesting minor in Osun COVID-19: Nigeria adopts 16 International Standards on essential electro-medical equipment- SON Lai Mohammed mourns late Kwara Chief of Staff Kwara Govt to revamp economy through tourism — Commissioner Foreign Ministry needs more funding to be more responsive – Onyeama How Unilorin is using its radio to fight COVID-19 – Manager Reps begin power sector gridlocks investigations 2 men arraigned in court for allegedly stealing goods, cash totalling N226,000 NASFAT establishes HAVEK Leadership Academy to produce exceptional young leaders Delta Govt. to go tough on violators of COVID-19 protocols – Commissioner NSE donates 3,800 face masks to Edo govt Trespass: Court orders NAF to pay N5m general damages CoS death: Kwara govt. officials proceed on self-isolation Bauchi emir tasks NAHCON leadership on transparency Lagos receives 16 vehicles from Shell ECO Currency: convergence criteria must be met for sustainability – Onyeama Don identifies renewable energy as panacea to curb incessant collapse of national grid Female lawyers hail passage of sexual harassment prohibition bill EU secures potential COVID-19 drugs from Roche, Germany’s Merck — Source Insecurity: Nigerian Army graduates 1,151 special forces Onyeama says Adesina, most successful AfDB’s President Oncologist calls for routine checks for early detection of NCDs Gov. Bello appoints Justices Olusiyi, Olowosegun as Kogi Ag. CJ, President of Customary Court of Appeal Buhari seeks Senate’s replacement of two non-career Ambassadors-designate 7 die in NNPC explosion at Benin River Valve Station Magu: Group urges thorough investigation Kwara Speaker mourns Gov. AbdulRazaq’s Chief of Staff Ondo records 76 fresh COVID-19 cases in 1 day Domestic violence: Police arrest woman for allegedly killing husband in Abia COVID-19: Adamawa Govt fixes Aug. 4 for schools’ resumption COVID-19: GSK holds 2019 AGM by proxy July 23 COVID-19: Ondo isolation centres remain open–Commissioner EFCC re-arraigns member, Presidential Arms Probe Panel over alleged money laundering, illegal arms possession BMO lauds President Buhari’s debt relief for television, radio stations Consumer Rights: Group calls for intensified education of consumers in rural areas Gov. Sule lauds Buhari for Ajaokuta-Kaduna-Kano Gas Pipeline project Prominent people diagnosed with COVID-19 As virus cases rise, Iranian leader bans wedding, funeral ceremonies NEPZA warns officials against violating financial regulations Accidents: Ogun assembly wants more traffic officers on highways BMO lauds President Buhari’s decision to suspend Magu LASG warns against fraudsters posing as its estate agents German cabinet passes first ever gender equality strategy Police confirm arrest of ritualist, other suspects linked to killings in Oyo State LBIC General Manger tasks staff on hardwork, transparency Man accused of stealing neighbour’s phones remanded Nasarawa bye-election: Voters must use face masks – INEC Paucity of funds slowing intervention, evacuation of Nigerians in Diaspora – Onyeama COVID-19: FRSC commences massive nationwide education, training COVID-19: AIG partners NESG on Incidence, Response Tracker for containment Monarch lauds military interventions on tackling banditry in Sokoto Psychiatric Hospital workers protest COVID-19 hazard allowance shortfall Some COVID-19 patients can be managed at home – Specialist Catalonia introduces tough mask-wearing policy Forum endorses Oyefusi for Lagos East Senatorial By-election Assembly tasks Kano State Government on potable water supply at the metropolis Alleged illegal sealing: Firm drags Ebonyi govt to court, seeks N500m German, Austrian police raid premises of 12 suspected weapons dealers Social Register: Kaduna commences capturing of poor households in 14 LGAs COVID-19: Elumelu tests negative, urges lawmakers to undergo screening Internet fraud: expert urges customers to beware of ‘Audio’ Sellers Education minister solicits World Bank support for out-of- school children Federal Character Commission to audit MDAs nominal rolls Pellegrini set to coach Real Betis ‘My father handed over money Sen. Sani returned to the EFCC as exhibit’, witness tells court COVID-19: NMA suspends strike in C/River Court in Pakistan denies bail to media tycoon held without charges FMDQ Securities Exchange posts N11.78trn turnover in May NIMET conducts virtual training on rainfall prediction for farmers in Plateau Institute provides shelter for 95-year-old woman in Bayelsa Viral video: FRSC orders prosecution of driver, investigation of patrol team European Commission plans to expand hydrogen power Gunmen kill District Head of Bajida in Kebbi EU court trims €82m cartel fine on chip maker Infineon Rainy season: farmer calls for proper drainages to avert crop losses Tottenham’s Dier gets four-game ban for confronting fan DG appeals for effective coordination to enhance C ‘River AIDS, STIs programme Troops kill 17 terrorists, loses 2 soldiers in Damboa ambush – DHQ Former African heavyweight boxing champion recovers from cancer Nigeria inclusion into UN Security Council, future goal, says Onyeama COVID-19: Domestic flights resume at Lagos Airport Police arrest bandit, wife with 2 AK 47 rifles in Kebbi China says United States withdrawal from WHO undermines fight against COVID-19 French premier defends new interior minister accused of rape Dana Air resumes flight July 9 Oyo CAN seeks God’s intervention on COVID-19, rape, others Gov. Sule reiterates commitment to quality, affordable education in Nasarawa State Lopsided appointments’ report unfounded, false – NPA Air Peace resumes domestic flights, guarantees passengers’ safety Chief of Staff burial will follow COVID-19 protocols – Kwara Govt Facebook not doing enough to fight discrimination, audit says PFN lauds Nweke, Ogbonna, for their exemplary act of honesty Netanyahu lawyer quits 11 days before corruption trial continues Ijaw Youth Council postpones national elections to July 17 Politicians, officials in S. Korea owning multiple houses under growing pressure to sell News Flash: Federal Character Commission to audit Nominal Roll of Agencies 2 men in court over alleged N890,000 fraud FRSC alerts motorists on imminent diversion on Lagos 3rd mainland bridge Gov. Bello wants immediate rehabilitation of Minna city gate-Chanchaga road Trump says he is open to another summit with N.K. leader – Reports Houses without decent toilet facilities encourage raping of females – NAWOJ Ministries of Aviation, Education, others make presentations at FEC meeting FIRS extends tax debt payments to Aug. 31 Nasarawa Fire Service records 99 fire incidents from January to June NDA reaffirms commitment to turn out best officers Alleged N471m fraud: Court fixes Oct. 20 for ex-HoS, Oyo-Ita’s trial Onyeama extols Nigeria’s security as top success story Kanye West breaks ranks with Trump, vows to win presidential race  Mongolia’s new government sworn in Gov. Bagudu appoints 5 new District Heads, 1 Councillor  COVID-19 pandemic plunges working world into crisis- ILO Britain to announce jobs, housing boost for coronavirus-hit economy Family announces burial arrangement of pioneer NAN staff, Samuel Ajibola French PM says any new coronavirus lockdown would be targeted Serbian police arrest 23 in Belgrade riot against virus restrictions Customers decry poor compliance to COVID-19 guidelines by some banks Japan supercomputer suggests changes to travel, work amid airborne virus threat S/Korean CEO among 12 held for deadly gas leak in India UNESCO declares Indonesia’s Toba Caldera as Global Geopark China hires Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs to advise on pipeline asset transfers – sources China to impose visa restrictions on United States citizens over Tibet Federal High Court begins annual vacation July 27 Kanye West breaks ranks with Trump, vows to win United States presidential race: Forbes New study warns of brain damages linked to COVID-19 Masks, disinfectant, social distancing: Japan responds to disaster amid coronavirus Duterte says law-abiding Filipinos should not fear anti-terrorism law Troops inflict heavy casualty on Boko Haram terrorists in Borno – DHQ Credit Suisse aims for 100% of securities venture in China growth plan Enugu State records 37 new cases of COVID-19 infections Oil edges lower as United States inventory build stokes supply fears United States envoy plays down expectations for North Korea meet, but ready to talk China converts Hong Kong hotel into new national security office Merkel to meet EU heads in Brussels to discuss economic recovery ITC launches groundbreaking tool to track policies for women in trade AfCFTA, powerful tool for integration–ECA Hoodlums vandalise pipeline at Aboru for fuel theft – LASEMA NGO seeks review of drug abuse policy