Connect with us

Judiciary

Court overrules Maina’s plea to reject EFCC evidence against him

Published

on

Court overrules Maina’s plea to reject EFCC evidence against him

Justice Okon Abang of the Abuja Federal High Court on Monday overruled Abdulrasheed Maina’s plea to reject documented evidence presented against him by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC).


  not in a position to determine before the court which document was relevant to the case of the prosecution.

He said that any document the prosecution decided to bring before the court to proof their case, provided it was admissible to the law, such documents will be admitted in evidence.

He however noted that whether the court will consider the document relevant to a case before it, was entirely a different issue.

“It is a case of the prosecution and not the defendant, the defendants have not opened their defence.

“It is possible that at the close of the case of the prosecution, the defendants may or may not call evidence in the matter.

“ Put differently, the defendants may decide to file a no case application at the close of the case of the prosecution. If the no case application succeeds then the defendants may not call evidence in the matter.

“ It is only when the no case application fails that the defendants may decide to call evidence in the matter.

“In a like manner, it is not for the prosecution to determine which document is relevant to the case of the defendant,” he said.

The Judge further said that when a defendant decides to call evidence in a matter, any document that the defendant decides to bring to court to proof their innocence will be provided in evidence.

Nigeria News Agency reports that the 1st and 2nd defendants were; Maina and Common Input Property and Investment Ltd, respectively.

EFCC Prosecutor, Mr Farouk Abdullahi, presented a set of five documents indicating the bank statement of accounts, account opening and certificate of identification belonging to Maina and four others as evidence.

The four others were; Kangolo Dynamic Cleaning Services, Drew Investment and Construction Limited, Clister Logistics and Nafisatu Aliyu.

  documents as Exhibit D1, Exhibit D2, Exhibit D3, Exhibit D4 and Exhibit D5.

He said that because the matter was for continuation of trial, he was ready to present the third prosecution witness (PW3).

PW3, Mr Marvis Enabulele, Compliance Officer at a Financial Institution said he served as a witness in the case in respect to a request by the EFCC to provide information on certain accounts in 2019.

Enabulele acknowledged that the accounts information retrieved were that of; Abdulrashid Maina, Cluster Logistics, Kangolo Dynamic Cleaning Services, Nafisatu Aliyu and Trew Investment and Construction Limited.

“We got the information from the archives and data base system of the bank.

“After printing, we also compared what we printed to what was on the bank’s system for accuracy,” he said.

Enabulele after identifying copies of the documents, Abdullahi tendered the 5 sets of documents before the court and urged the court to admit and mark as exhibits.

  urged the court to reject the documents tendered.

“ The documents are irrelevant, of no use and not related with the charges before the court and also not reflected to the proof of evidence,” he said.

Counsel to the 2nd defendant, Mr Adeola Adedipe aligned with the submissions of Munguno.

In reaction, The prosecution insisted that the documents tendered were of paramount importance to the case.

“We want the court to see the proof of evidence, especially page 1060 and you will find out that the documents were attached to the proof of evidence.

“The documents are relevant and it does not lie in the mouths of the defendant counsels to say they are not relevant.

“Because, this is a criminal trial on 12 counts charge of money laundering through financial institutions.

“The documents have complied fully with the provision of the evidence ACT,” he said.

NAN also reports that Justice Abang informed the court that he was ready to hear the bail variation and continuation of trial as he adjourned the matter to Jan. 13th, 14th, 15th, 16th and 17th, 2020.

  Abang had on Nov. 25, 2019 admitted the defendant to bail in the sum of 1billion naira.

He ordered Maina to produce two sureties who must be serving senators.

He also ordered that the two sureties, who must be prepared for a N500m bond each, must always be in court with the defendant at each adjourned date.

According to the Judge, the two law makers provided must be free of any criminal trial in any court within the country.

The EFCC had, on Oct. 25, 2019 charged the defendant before the court alongside his firm, Common Input Property and Investment Ltd on a 12 count charge on money laundering.

Edited by: Sadiya Hamza

Kelechi Ogunleye: is a graduate and a professionally trained journalist, with experience in national news reporting/editing and verification at the News Agency of Nigeria. NNN is a Nigerian online news portal that publishes breaking news in Nigeria, and across the world. Our journalists are honest, fair, accurate, thorough and courageous in gathering, reporting and interpreting news in the best interest of the public, because truth is the cornerstone of journalism and they strive diligently to ascertain the truth in every news report. Contact: editor[at]nnn.com.ng

Halep to decide on United States Open after Prague event Gov. Fayemi mourns ex-Ekiti lawmaker, Fakiyesi Vettel says Ferrari messed up with nonsensical strategy Ekiti Govt paying lip service to healthcare delivery, say striking doctors Resumption: Academy wants COVID-19 protocol funds released directly to schools Willian confirms exit from Chelsea after 7 years Anglican Bishop urges govts to save SMEs from collapse For Europe’s “super clubs”, UEFA Champions League determines all YYA sues for peace in Ondo Assembly, condoles with Ogun over Kashamu Ilorin communities appeal to Gov. AbdulRazaq over damaged culvert NPFL 2019/2020 season: Rivers United still insisting they finished second, not third Imo Assembly restates commitment to local production through effective legislation CAN President urges FG to overhaul security apparatus  Osun: Police dismiss inspector for allegedly brutalising tailor, causing death Nimet predicts cloudy, thundery weather activities Monday to Wednesday Sanwo-Olu gives hospital’s management 7-day ultimatum to remove trucks, containers FG supports Imo farmers with 20,000 cocoa seedlings, other improved seeds COVID-19: Low attendance, strict compliance greet church re-opening in Lagos Ex-Rep wants Obaseki impeached over alleged breach of constitution NMA charges state branches to uphold values to protect members Unknown assailants kill Gov. Obiano’s aide on security DG APC Governors Forum tasks membership on participation, registration  Banditry: Monarch urges govt. to adopt new strategies Cleric tasks worshipers on COVID-19 guidelines as church services resume Kwara records 7 new cases of COVID-19 Beauty queen pledges to showcase cultural heritage of Northern Nigeria Zamfara agency sensitises communities on World Bank projects maintenance, sustainability Don’t smoke away your babies, Gynaecologist warns PDP BOT Chairman seeks conduct of LG election by INEC Community policing: FCT minister advocates involvement of council chairmen, traditional rulers Former Police boss blames security challenges on corruption, bad governance Southern Kaduna attacks: Coalition tasks locals on credible information to military Delta communities want FG to revive abandoned projects Dabiri-Erewa says Dapo William’s death great loss to Nigeria Rev Okoye urges Nigerians to return to God, shun tribalism, other vices Commission pledges to eradicate illiteracy, poverty in North-East FG, ECOWAS to host biodiversity consultation on environmental protection Journalists Forum uncovers Nigerians in critical situation in Saudi Arabia NOA urges collaboration of traditional leaders in fight against COVID-19 APC in UK pays tributes to late Dapo Williams Ekiti Govt distributes protective materials ahead Monday’s school reopening Kogi govt extends schools’ fumigation to Eastern Senatorial district Buhari mourns UK-based Nigerian, Dapo Williams COVID-19: Mosques in Ekiti ready for reopening – NSCIA COVID-19: Churches in Lagos  reopen, record  low turn out after 20 weeks of lockdown Church re-opening: Cleric wants leaders ensure compliance with COVID-19 guidelines FCTA pledges support to Suleja smart city project Evacuation: 327 Nigerians depart London for Abuja Resumption: Lagos churches comply with COVID-19 guidelines, as worship resumes Accident claims 2 lives in Anambra – FRSC