Connect with us

Judiciary

Court throws out EFCC’s plea to screen witness in Maina’s trial

Published

on

Court throws out EFCC’s plea to screen witness in Maina’s trial

The Federal High Court, Abuja, on Tuesday, dismissed the application by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) to screen its fourth prosecution witness (PW4) in the ongoing trial of Abdulrasheed Maina, ex-Pension Reform boss.


Justice Okon Abang gave the order after listening to arguments of counsel to the parties in the case.

The Nigeria News Agency reports that the act of screening a witness in a case is to afford the witness the opportunity to testify under shield to protect him or her from public view.

At the resumed trial on Tuesday, the anti-graft agency’s lawyer, Farouk Abdullahi, urged the court, shortly after the third witness completed its evidence in chief, to grant his request for the PW4 to testify in camera.

“I apply that my next witness be screened in accordance with Section 232 Dub 4c of ACJA.

“The application will not prejudice the trial of this case. I am not making the application to waste the judicial time of this honourable court,” he said.

Reacting, Counsel to Maina, Mohammed Monguno, objected to the application.

Monguno, who described the case as just a criminal trial, said the prosecution had breeched Section 232 Subsection 2 of the Administration of Criminal Justice Act (ACJA).

He argued that the identity of the proposed witness was no longer hidden as the witness’ name, address and phone number are in the proof of evidence which had already been circulated to the clients, the counsel, the registry, etc.

“More so, no reason was given for the application for the screening of the witness,” he remarked.

The lawyer further argued that the EFCC counsel did not inform them of his plan to have the witness screened.

Adeola Adedipe, Counsel to the 2nd defendant (Common Input Property Investment Ltd), supported Monguno’s submission..

“I adopt the submission of the counsel to the 1st defendant. We are here to give full cooperation to the court.

“The prosecution has failed to comply with the mandatory provision of Section 232 Sub 2 of the ACJA. It is an application predicated on nothing,” he added.

Justice Abang while addressing Abdullahi, said: “You have already disclosed the particulars of the proposed witness. So how do you want the court to screen the witness.”

Responding, Abdullahi, who admitted that the identity of the witness had already been made known, said their application was for the witness to be screened from gallery and not from the bar.

“Yes My Lord, it is correct that we have listed the name of the proposed witness in our list of witnesses.

“The penal legislation has not said that when a proposed witness is named, the witness cannot be screened.

“Our application is that the witness should be screened from gallery and not from the bar.

“The court is a court of justice and it has the power to do that. We want the witness to be heard and not to be seen. I therefore urge this honourable court to grant our application,” he said.

Abdullahi also regretted that the defence counsel were not informed about the decision to screen the proposed witness.

“I should have discussed this with the counsel to the defendant although it is not mandatory for the prosecution.

“It was not done in bad faith. Particularly, the defendant has nothing to lose. So I urge this honourable court to grant the application,” he said.

In his ruling, Justice Abang said he had carefully considered the argument of the defence counsel , arguing that the prosecution had already breeched Section 232 Sub 2 of ACJA..

He said he had also considered the argument of the prosecution in his reply on point of law.

However, the judge said that “the provisions of Section 232 Subsections 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 of ACJA guides the court on how to exercise its discretion as to whether or not a particular witness ought to be screened.”

He said for a witness to be screened, the prosecution must comply with the mandatory provision of Section 232 Subsection 2 of ACJA.

The judge said for a witness to be screened, the identity ought not to have been disclosed in the court record.

He said Abdullahi also admitted that the statement made by the witness also formed parts of the record of the court.

He said the prosecution also failed to tell the court that the proposed witness had been designated with combinations of alphabets.

Justice Abang, therefore, held that having disclosed the identity of the witness, the proposed witness cannot be screened.

He said the prosecution had breeched the relevant sections of the law.

According to him, the defence has a point here and the issue must be resolve in favour of the defence.

“This is an issue of law, not sentiment. The proposed fourth witness shall not be screened whether partially or otherwise,” the judge held.

Justice Abang then adjourned the trial continuation until Jan. 15.

Edited by: Sadiya Hamza

Taiye Agbaje: is a graduate and a professionally trained journalist, with experience in national news reporting/editing and verification at the News Agency of Nigeria. NNN is a Nigerian online news portal that publishes breaking news in Nigeria, and across the world. Our journalists are honest, fair, accurate, thorough and courageous in gathering, reporting and interpreting news in the best interest of the public, because truth is the cornerstone of journalism and they strive diligently to ascertain the truth in every news report. Contact: editor[at]nnn.com.ng

NSCDC pledges maximum support to Amotekun in Oyo state FG to pay June hazard allowance of medical workers from Aug. 10 Northern Governors condemn attacks in Southern Kaduna NAFDAC advises careful examination of products before buying Ooni tasks govt on food security as Ife celebrate yam festival Insecurity: CSOs call FG to intensify effort to allow farmers access farmlands COVID 19: Foundation begins online medical intervention COVID-19: PTF reverts govt working hours to 8a.m. to 4p.m. for GL 12 upward NIPC boss considers Shoprite strategic investment in Nigeria  UNDP, EU want strong legislation to end rape, violence against women Buhari sympathises with Lebanon over massive explosions Post-COVID-19: Feed miller urges youths to embrace agribusiness for sustainability to embrace agribusiness for sustainability COVID-19: United States lifts global travel advisory Prof. Sule, Plateau SUBEB boss, gets fresh tenure SSANU, NASU threaten strike over unresolved issues with FG Controller assures of professionalism in drug-related issues in custodian centres Insecurity: Peace corps cautions egocentric politicians, ethnic warlords We will harmonise all interests in Anambra FA, Caretaker Committee chairman assures Sevilla, Leverkusen cruise into Europa League quarter-finals Makinde names ex-legislator, commissioner as Board chairmen Amb. Dada calls for investigation into ECOWAS headquarters fire incident COVID-19: Buhari orders compulsory use of face masks nationwide NIPC partners with NBS on sectors’ assessment to boost investment Kano Emir Bayero says EPZ will spur national industrial dev’t Happening in Edo threat to constitutional order – Atiku FG not frustrating evacuation of Nigerian students in Saudi Arabia – official Defence College graduates 107 foreign, local participants of Course 28 Army, DICON, security firm sign MoU on military equipment production FirstBank has processed N6trn transactions through FirstMonie network — Adeduntan INEC introduces election result viewing portal PenCom to initiate pension reform act 2014 review Religious, traditional leaders pledge support to fight rape, violence against women NIPC urges deep economic reforms to reverse 2020-2021 investment decline US agency warns hurricane season this year could be one of the worst INEC threatens to halt Edo, Ondo polls if there is violence Credible election in Edo will rekindle Nigerians’ hope- Secondus Around 40 migrants drown in shipwreck off Mauritanian coast COVID-19: Again FG extends second phase of eased restrictions by 4 week Gold price continues to fly high, rises to yet another record Female senator donates 21 trailer-load of fertilisers to Adamawa farmers Military allays fear over alleged Al-Qaeda, ISIS inroad to Nigeria NCPC partners CAN, JNI to end Southern Kaduna killings COVID-19: PTF approves gradual reopening of international flights LASG calls for synergy among security agencies COVID-19: Kogi Govt fumigates schools ahead of resumption on Aug. 10 Gov Ikpeazu calls for Federal Secretariat in Abia Asaba Airport to resume operation soon – Delta SSG APC appoints acting state chairman in Akwa Ibom NCC tasks ICT reporters to work in synergy with Commission COVID-19: Coy launches `BackToWork’ safety module for businesses, organisations