Connect with us

Judiciary

Lawyers back Supreme Court judgment on virtual court proceedings

Published

on

Lawyers back Supreme Court judgment on virtual court proceedings

Some Lagos-based lawyers on Tuesday said the Supreme Court decision on the constitutionality of virtual court proceedings was influenced more by the exigencies of the moment.


They said that virtual court hearing have become a necessity in the face of the COVID-19 pandemic.

The lawyers made their views known in interviews with the News Agency of Nigeria .

NAN reports that the Supreme Court on Tuesday struck out a suit filed by the Attorneys-General of Lagos and Ekiti states challenging the legality of virtual court sittings.

In an unanimous decision, a seven-man panel led by Justice Olabode Rhodes-Vivour held that as at today, virtual court sittings are not unconstitutional.

NAN reports that Lagos State attorney-general had asked the Supreme Court to determine whether, having regard to Section 36(1), (3) and (4) of the 1999 Constitution (as amended), the use of technology by remote hearings of any kind, by the Lagos State High Court or any other courts in Nigeria in aid of hearing and determination of cases, is constitutional.

The Minister of Justice and the Attorney-General of the Federation (AGF) Abubakar Malami (SAN) had given a directive to the heads of courts at the federal and state levels to adopt virtual court sittings.

A lawyer, Mr Osuala Nwagbara, told NAN that virtual court procedure was not unconstitutional because the Constitution provided for an aggrieved persons to ventilate their rights through the courts and for accused persons to be given facilities to defend themselves.

He, therefore, said virtual court hearing was a procedural way to ventilate such rights.

Nwagbara added that such a process did not rob any one of the right to be heard either in support of his claim, complaint or defence.

“Virtual court hearing has, in fact, become a necessity in the face of the COVID-19 pandemic.

“On the contrary, not to devise a safe court proceedings now will amount to shutting people out of their rights to ventilate their grievances or defend themselves,” Nwagbara said.

He also said that the process did not make a complainant a judge in his own cause.

According to him, the process follows the age-long tradition that an unbiased and independent umpire, a judge, sits and resolves disputes or complaints.

“Whichever way one looks at the virtual Court hearing procedure, it is not unconstitutional,” he said.

Another lawyer, Mr Chibuikem Opara, said, “I think the Supreme Court’s judgment was influenced more by the exigencies of the moment than the constitution.

“In any event, it is better to apply the law liberally than to insist on rigid and sometimes harsh interpretations that will only result in hardship.

“These are unusual times and rigidity to the interpretation of extant provisions will only bring more hardship.

“I strongly believe that there is need to amend the constitution to expressly embody the judgment.”

Mr Chris Ayiyi, also a lawyer, said that the judgement was based on the condition at hand.

He, howeve, said that the face value of the judgement was correct but the cost effectiveness of the virtual Court sitting was not considered.

Ayiyi said that the apex court should have considered the cost of virtual proceedings on ordinary people.

“To this end, if you don’t have money, you cannot pursue your legal right, if it is infringed on.

“A review of the judgement will come when we, as a people, start experiencing lumpsided judgement,” he said.

Edited By: Olawunmi Ashafa/Ijeoma Popoola (NAN)

Omeire Cecilia: is a graduate and a professionally trained journalist, with experience in national news reporting/editing and verification at the News Agency of Nigeria. NNN is a Nigerian online news portal that publishes breaking news in Nigeria, and across the world. Our journalists are honest, fair, accurate, thorough and courageous in gathering, reporting and interpreting news in the best interest of the public, because truth is the cornerstone of journalism and they strive diligently to ascertain the truth in every news report. Contact: editor[at]nnn.com.ng

Amotekun commander solicits Ondo monarchs’, residents’ support Actualising Life’s dreams entails strong determination, says Nollywood actor National gas transportation network code to go-live Monday — Official Mauritius declares state of emergency on environment after oil spill United States imposes sanctions on Central African rebel leader Lebanese judge orders detention of top officials after port blast FG evacuates 325 more Nigerians from United States in 6th special flight Italy extends coronavirus restrictions, allows cruise ships to sail Cuba keeps Havana airport closed as coronavirus cases spike Nigeria: NCDC announces 443 new COVID-19 cases, total infections now 45,687 United States stimulus talks collapse, setting stage for Trump executive orders Devastated Sarri says he can’t be judged on basis of one match American golfer disqualified from PGA Championship after scoring error Ronaldinho inches closer to release from Paraguayan ordeal Edo polls: U.S expresses worry over deteriorating political climate, security interference 2020: China interfering against Trump, Russia against Biden — report NOSDRA, Agip investigate oil leak at Azuzuama, Bayelsa Environmental group urges African governments to rise against COVID-19, Climate and Health crises Police arrest suspects for criminal offenses, kill 1 in Niger Chelsea’s Kante ruled fit against Bayern-Lampard Gattuso says his Napoli are not just about grit and growls UCL: Ronaldo brace not enough as Olympique Lyon knock out Juventus UCL:Man City eliminate Real Madrid after Varane nightmare Resumption: Kogi govt. tasks heads of schools on conducive environment Kano Varsity promotes 17 lecturers to professors, associate professors KEKE Senior Grammar School, others excel in Y2020 Goveŕnors quiz competition Maximising the benefits of breastfeeding during COVID-19 pandemic Ministries of Defence, Enviroment to synergise on protection of N’Delta environment Sanwo-Olu pledges to revitalise agric sector SUNU Assurances declares N1.2bn profit Kogi acting CJ pledges to sustain late Ajanah’s legacies Abia stakeholders pass vote of no confidence in Rep. Nkole over alleged poor performance Edo election: Security council condemns violence – Obaseki, CP PDP governors’ forum urges security agencies to re-strategise to curb insecurity Commissioner decries parents’ attitude over students lateness to schools in Delta GLEIF reaffirms CSCS as sole local operating unit Buhari greets Labour Minister, Chris Ngige at 68 Women groups rally support for Obaseki, Speaker in Edo Kano traffic agency bans long vehicles from offloading goods during the day Flood destroys 110 houses in Zamfara Kaduna attacks: Sen Sani urges concerted efforts by govt, security agencies Flooding: NEMA urges Jalingo residents to avoid settlement along riverine areas Zamfara APC Crisis: Court dissolves Zamfara executives, orders fresh congresses NBBF mourns former D’Tigers invitee, Ojo Adamawa Assembly approves Gov. Fintiri’s N550m Agric loan  ACF urges FG to tackle killings, insecurity in southern Kaduna Insecurity: Umahi advises Buhari to retain service chiefs Man, 27, drowns in Kano pond COVID-19 : EKSG introduces tax relief, incentives for businesses Apapa congestion : NUPENG directs tanker drivers to suspend services in Lagos