Connect with us

Judiciary

PDP, Atiku file appeal at Supreme Court over Tribunal judgment

Published

on

The Peoples Democratic Party, its presidential candidate in the Feb.  23 election, Atiku Abubakar, have formally filed their 66 grounds of appeal against the judgment of the Presidential Election Petition Tribunal at the Supreme Court.

Chief Mike Ozekhome, SAN, a senior lawyer in the legal team of Atiku and PDP, disclosed that the appeal was predicated on 66 grounds, which they believed Justices of the tribunal erred in their verdict on Atiku and PDP’s petition against the election of President Muhammadu Buhari.

The five-member panel led by Justice Mohammed Garba had in its judgment delivered on Sept. 11, dismissed the petition filed by Atiku and PDP for being incompetent and lacking in merit.

The panel in dismissing the petition held that Atiku and PDP were unable to substantiate their allegations that the election was rigged in favour of Buhari and the APC.

They further held that the petitioners did not produce relevant witnesses to convince them that Buhari did not possess necessary educational qualification for the office of the President of the Federal Republic of Nigeria.

Alhough Ozekhome did not list any of the 66 grounds on which the appeal was predicated.

The appeal is centered on issues bordering around the qualification of Buhari in the election and the controversial Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC’s) server amongst others.

Among the grounds listed included claims that the judgement of the tribunal was not based on the issues canvassed by the petitioners, especially in relation to the respondent’s academic qualifications.

“Take, for instance, one of the respondent’s witnesses, rtd Maj.-Gen. Paul Tarfa, called by President Muhammadu Buhari’s lawyers said that they did not give their qualifications to the Military Board. Tarfa’s testimony is against the claim by Buhari that the Nigeria military is in possession of his certificates.

“Secondly, Buhari said that he was recruited into the military in 1961 and Tarfa said in 1962, so what is the correct date of his recruitment into the army. Somebody is not telling the truth.

“The issue in question is who entered the different grades for him from both the Cambridge and the West African School Certificate results.

This is the first time that the court will say that the documents are admitted in the interest of justice. So, who entered the different grades for him and if he did it, why?

Another ground of appeal is that the President’s Chief of Staff, Abba Kyari, brought the Cambridge documents dated July 18 and testified on July 20.

The point here is that it was not pleaded, when the respondent replied to the petition of Atiku and PDP. The position of the appellants is that in law, you don’t speak on documents not pleaded.

The appellants are also claiming that the WAEC documents contradicted the Cambridge documents, describing it as a case of forgery and inconsistency in documents.

“On the INEC server, the judgement of the PEPT said the INEC server was hacked and we then asked, which of the servers was hacked?

“The tribunal judgment was based on the Electoral Act section 52 (1) (B), but this aspect of the law has since been deleted in 2015. It is no longer in existence. This was the case in Wike Vs Peterside.

”If the judgment said INEC server was recklessly hacked, then, there is a server and, therefore, a criminal offence. Yet, INEC did not claim so or that its documents were stolen.

”How come the judge reached this scandalous decision?

The appellants are there praying the apex court to hold that the tribunal erred in its decision and consequently set the tribunal’s judgment aside and go ahead to grant all the reliefs sought.

Atiku and his party, PDP had dragged the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) before the tribunal for declaring Buhari as winner of the Feb. 23 presidential election.

Mentioned as respondents are the electoral umpire include President Buhari and his party, the All Progressives Congress (APC).

In the petition filed on March 18, the petitioners amongst other things alleged that INEC in connivance with agencies of the ruling government manipulated the outcome of the poll in favour of Buhari.

They further alleged that Buhari at the time of contesting the poll was not qualified having not possessed requisite academic qualification and as such all votes credited to him in the election be regarded as wasted votes.

Atiku and PDP in the petition therefore urged the tribunal to nullify the emergence of Buhari on grounds of alleged Irregularities, rigging, substantial non compliance with the electoral provisions amongst others.

dismissed the petition for being incompetent and lacking in merit.

The tribunal resolved all issues raised by the petitioners in favour of Buhari, adding that the president did not lie but indeed possessed the mandatory qualification and even much more to contest for the presidential election.

While arguing that the failure of Buhari in not attaching the said certifcates in his form CF 001 did not amount to not having the certifcates, Justice Garba held that there is no law that requires the attachment of certifcates to the form CF001 submitted to INEC to aid his clearance for the February 23 presidential poll.

“It is established that a candidate is not required under the Electoral Act to attach his certificate to his Form CF001 before a candidate is adjudged to have the requisite qualification to contest the election.”

The tribunal in his conclusion on the issue said both oral and documentary evidence before it proved that Buhari has more than secondary school certificate required to contest the election.

“Second respondent has more than secondary school certificate having attended various courses. He is not only qualified, he is eminently qualified”, the tribunal said.

Dissatisfied, the petitioners had approached the apex court to reverse the judgment of the tribunal.

EPA/SH

edited by Sadiya Hamza

 

Ebere Agozie: is a graduate and a professionally trained journalist, with experience in national news reporting/editing and verification at the News Agency of Nigeria. NNN is a Nigerian online news portal that publishes breaking news in Nigeria, and across the world. Our journalists are honest, fair, accurate, thorough and courageous in gathering, reporting and interpreting news in the best interest of the public, because truth is the cornerstone of journalism and they strive diligently to ascertain the truth in every news report. Contact: editor[at]nnn.com.ng

Contact US: editor @nnn.com.ng, nnnnews247 @gmail.com

I-G orders posting, redeployment of senior officers Chief Judge releases 24 inmates, grants 53 others bail in Enugu State COVID-19: Lagos to charge face mask defaulters to court COVID-19: NLC calls for education stakeholders meeting on safe school re-opening Ondo 2020: Odimayo appoints campaign DG, others Dyche’s achievements at Burnley exemplary for promoted clubs, says Wilder Special prosecutor to examine allegations against FIFA boss, Swiss Attorney General Liverpool reiterate need for safe celebrations, ahead Villa clash Police arraign man, 42, over alleged motorcycle theft Norwich’s Farke says turned down job offers this season Police arraign 2 men over alleged breach of peace in Ekiti FIFA investigating West Ham over Haller transfer COVID-19: NGO lifts Kwara rural communities with palliative Canada’s biggest banks join boycott of Facebook platforms NECA urges FG to lift suspension placed on NSITF boss, others Macron appoints new PM in search for fresh momentum No Christmas presents for youngsters, warns Klopp Nigerians in Diaspora group donates N48m PPE to PTF Tourism practitioners harp on therapeutic effect of exploring nature Group seeks probe of attack on FMC, Lokoja Schools reopening: Beware of paedophiles – NGO tells proprietors, parents DSS arrests impersonator in Taraba Insurgency: NAF takes delivery of newly reactivated ATR-42 aircraft COVID-19: Kwara receives N243m donations from individuals, organisations – AbdulRazaq Polio-Free Status: Buhari writes “Letters of Appreciation’’ to Osinbajo, Sultan, World leaders FG distributes fertilisers to flood victims in Kwara NSIA records N36.15bn total comprehensive income in 2019 NiMet predicts cloudy, thundery weather Saturday to Monday Ondo guber: 2 PDP aspirants fail screening Anambra 2021: PDP chief urges members to embrace peace, unity My mum inspires my creative career — Ex-BBnaija housemate, Elozonam Ex-TUC chairman calls for resuscitation of nation’s refineries Gov. Oyetola extols late Ooni Adesoji Aderemi virtues, 40 years after COVID-19: LASG reopens schools in August Lampard wants ‘collective sit-down’ over VAR controversies Jjgawa PDP wants more united party at grassroots Kaduna completes first phase of ultra modern market  Kwara commends BUA Group for donating 3 ambulances UNN-ASUU warns members to boycott July 6 Deanship election Don’t break govt seals on properties sealed for breaking laws- LASG Lawmaker lauds NAYES for curbing crimes in Nasarawa We need sustained efforts to maintain polio-free status —— NIMR D-G Saints bracing for stern test against Manchester City, says Hasenhuettl Kwara Gov reshuffles cabinet, moves 5 commissioners Kogi gets acting Chief Judge Do not judge Leicester on last four games, says Rodgers Philippine leader signs controversial anti-terrorism law Hodgson not worried by trip to locked down Leicester COVID-19: Edo Govt. warns against reopening of schools COVID-19: Edo discharges 80 more patients LASG disburses funds to 300 victims of Abule-Egba pipeline explosion “I’ll name my prince Adesoji Aderemi” – Ooni Ogunwusi NIS arrests alleged kidnapper, murderer in Oyo Herder/farmer clash: Bauchi suspends Emir of Misau, others Alleged cultism: Ilaro Poly reinstates suspended SUG president  BUA to set up 3m metric tonnes cement plant in Adamawa Gov. Lalong mourns LG Chair in Plateau, Mandyau ASUU president urges FG to tackle challenges affecting education, health sectors ICT expert advocates compulsory computer training for civil servants Police commission approves promotion of 6,681 senior officers NDDC urges residents to monitor projects in Niger Delta communities Mobile court orders 5 traders to cut grass at Govt’s house in Benin Effective system will realise $10 crude oil production cost target -Expert NSITF suspension: NECA calls for respect of rule of law Kim Jong Un says N/Korea prevented coronavirus from making inroads Pharmacists’ Council shuts drug market, seals 19 pharmacies Failed Surgery: Lagos surgeon, clinic arraigned for allegedly evading investigation Olofa of Offa congratulates new FCC Chairman Goodluck Jonathan Foundation donates items to states EFCC has not dropped charges against Adoke -Spokesman NSE: Shares traded down 19.88% Lagos records 3 new COVID-19 related deaths Organised labour flays unfair labour practices NPA expects 33 ships with petroleum products, others at Lagos port Suspected robbers kill bank customer, cart away cash in Bayelsa Edo polls: UK Chapter of APC raises campaign council for Ize-Iyamu Embrace farming for financial stability – agriculturist tells unemployed Ugwuanyi inaugurates rice seed multiplication farm in Enugu State July PMS price indicates government readiness to exit subsidy –Don NACCIMA pledges support to Prof. Adesugba as NEPZA MD Gov. Ikpeazu swears in 13 new permanent secretaries Osun commissioner commends IITA for distributing farming inputs to farmers NCDMB signs agreements on Energy park, oil blending plant COVID-19: CSOs train 165 vulnerable women, youths on face mask, sanitiser production Police arraign man, 27, for allegedly assaulting woman in Benin Post COVID-19: FG to implement report on Creative Industry – Lai Mohammed Speaker hails peaceful conduct of NUJ elections COVID-19: Delta CJ directs judicial staff to work 3 times a week Commission expresses commitment to generate revenue from water sector UNESCO, ECOWAS sign MoU on COVID-19 response Board recommends PRODA D-G suspension over misconduct Expert links cognitive decline to use of agricultural pesticides LETI tasks newly trained CBD officers on professionalism, integrity German lawmakers vote to make ‘upskirting’ a crime Cleric admonish Muslims against worldly trappings German football federation made near 20m euros profit in 2019 Alleged N127.1m fraud: Court admits ex-Scholarship Board boss to N10m bail Aba markets resume normal businesses as govt eases lockdown Behave yourselves, UK PM Johnson warns as pubs get ready to pull pints again Special prosecutor to examine allegations against Infantino, Swiss Attorney-General Czech striker Baros to quit at season’s end Kano anti-corruption boss urges FG to checkmate fraud in rice production AfCFTA: LADOL boss says local production is key to servicing trade Sponsor FedEx urges Washington Redskins to change name Blasts at Turkish fireworks factory kill 2, wound 73 Commission warns against indiscriminate drilling of borehole Coalition of Pastoralists seeks prosecution of Zangon Kataf killings perpetrators Man in court over alleged N3.6m visa fraud, club placement Islamic State supporter jailed for plot to bomb London cathedral Agro firm invests in palm nut cracker, milling plants Association wants hippopotamus killers in Kebbi prosecuted Court remands man for allegedly defiling his 3-year-old daughter COVID-19 Spike: NUJ urges 14 days lockdown in Ondo Mercedes in first two positions as F1 gets back on track in Austria Buhari pays tribute to Late Ooni Aderemi, lauds his good deeds Court orders Public Defender to takeover alleged kidnapper, Evans’ case Remdesivir first Covid-19 drug to receive EU’s green light China logistics prosperity index rebounds 0.1% points to 54.9% in June Edo 2020: PDP pledges all-inclusive, realistic Govt in Edo Travel agent in court over alleged N2.9m visa scam Kaduna social protection policy will rescue residents from poverty – Report Expert advises pregnant women to stay hydrated Tennis wonderkid Gauff can improve the world, Navratilova says Serbia imposes COVID-19 restrictions in Belgrade Face mask: Police arrest 121 violators in Akwa Ibom Revolutionising Nigeria’s dairy sector via Kano State approach Angolan app gives performers a lifeline-streaming to paying public Kano conducts 12,918 COVID-19 samples test Yobe Govt., NGO train 150 midwives Street children: Group urges C’River govt to implement Child Rights law UCTH confirms 5 COVID-19 positive cases in Calabar Hong Kong man first to be charged with inciting secession, terrorism COVID-19: Association calls for more youth participation in agribusiness Unmask Boko Haram members sighted in your markets- GOC urges traders in Maiduguri German lawmakers pass bill to phase out coal by 2038 NACC appoints Obadimu as DG Bank customers decry arbitrary deductions, hails bank for refund COVID-19: 10,000 farmers to get firm’s fertiliser subsidy in Sokoto Man seeks divorce over alleged sex starvation in Ibadan Kebbi Govt donates 3 vehicles to police to enhance security Cambodian PM says casinos can be re-opened if they meet requirements for COVID-19 prevention Ondo election: APC generates N258m from sales of forms Osun govt. commiserates with Gov. Akeredolu over health commissioner’s death Alleged $1bn cloned account: NPA welcomes House of Reps investigation Russia’s COVID-19 cases rise to 667,883 FRSC partners NIS on irregular migration India’s first COVID-19 vaccine may be launched by Aug. 15  Japan asks United States to extradite 2 men accused of aiding Ghosn’s escape French PM Philippe resigns as Macron readies reshuffle Sen. Gyang mourns Plateau LG chairman Sane completes move to Bayern from Manchester City Google-backed groups criticise Apple’s new warnings on user tracking Ex-CBN Director tasks FG on ailing refineries Again, Nigerian troops hit terrorists’ meeting venue, kill several fighters in Borno COVID-19: CMD urges improved health infrastructure Former commissioner urges dialogue between NASS, Executive over 774,000  jobs’ recruitment Edo 2020: No PDP aspirant will be unjustly disqualified- Dogara NITDA calls for upscaling quality on indigenous devices 12 youths renounce cult membership in Delta We’ve no differences to sort out in APC, says Tinubu Nigeria records 626 new COVID-19 cases as total climbs to 27,110 Messi unwilling to renew Barca contract COVID-19: Expert suggests 4 areas of reportage in Africa Real Madrid close in on La Liga title as Ramos strike sinks Getafe Spurs lose 1-3 at Sheffield United, after another VAR controversy Referees are now in the office, not pitch — Mourinho Manchester City honour Liverpool, then hammer them 4-0 United States COVID-19 assistance to Nigeria hits N15.5bn UN suspends 2 employees over viral sex video Plateau: Chairman of Barkin-Ladi LGA dies at 52 COVID-19: PTF cautions Nigerians on eased restrictions Delta Assembly prays for speedy recovery of Gov Okowa’s family Ekiti PDP promises transparent congress COVID-19: Farmers laud Buhari for distributing inputs,  palliatives  Ex-Lagos lawmaker receives award of excellence from Ghanaian institute Late health commissioner, a reliable colleague, compatriot – Gov. Akeredolu Police clear hide out, arrest over 32 suspects in Enugu PDP screens aspirants for Ondo governorship poll Secretariat expansion: Sokoto Head of Service seeks Assembly’s intervention NSCDC arrests 11 suspects, impounds three trucks of crude oil in Delta COVID-19: Niger Assembly requests update on activities of task force ACI, Coca-Cola engage 100 residents to pick plastics for cleaner Lagos Ondo govt declares 7-day mourning for health commissioner Abuja National Hospital treats 50,000 patients in 6 months – CMD LASG begins fund disbursement to Abule-Egba pipeline explosion victims I-G tasks officers on regular medical care Lagos says‘ll stop reclaimed lands approvals in posh Banana Island COVID-19: No time frame for train service resumption – PTF Bayelsa Govt assures athletes of support, sets to clear outstanding bonuses Osun records 24 new COVID-19 cases, discharges 11 Islamic clerics offer special prayers against banditry, COVID-19 in Katsina PDP dissolves South West zonal caretaker committee, constitutes new one Police arrest 14 suspects over criminal conspiracy, rape in Sokoto COVID-19: FG distributes improved cashew seeds, fertiliser, other to Kogi farmers Father allegedly rapes, impregranates 17-year-old daughter in Adamawa 774, 000 Jobs: Adhere to principle of separation of powers, group tells NASS Djokovic, wife test negative for COVID-19 Assembly, Nasarawa Govt. to collaborate on education COVID-19: Physically challenged persons pray for Gov. Okowa, others Technology advancement, key to improve productivity in teaching, learning — DG NITDA Okada riders protest incessant extortion, arrest by police in Lagos Brighton boss Potter pleased by results since season resumption We’ll ensure culprits in Akinyele killings are arrested – Oyo CP COVID-19: We have not relaxed ban on mass gatherings – NCDC   COVID-19: FG activates all FCT public hospitals for sample collection AbdulRazaq congratulates Kwara ambassador nominees Serie A picks Lazard as adviser to weigh private equity bids – sources No fans at La Liga stadiums for rest of the season, say organisers APC mourns Ondo Health Commissioner Computer professionals call for proper registration of members Court rejects Rivers’ request for interim stoppage of police fund deductions FG distributes fertiliser to farmers in Kogi STF troops kill 2 suspected armed robbers in Jos Kano announces total easing of lockdown Airports re-opening: Aides of VIPs will not enter airports — Minister A’Ibom Assembly committee decries slow pace of work on road projects COVID-19: Capital market committee donates ambulances, medical items to FCTA, Kano, Lagos states Enugu community resort to self-help over deplorable state of road Enugu community laments scarcity of water, appeals for assistance Kwara college speaks on discovery of 2,000 fake certificates Inter signs Moroccan full back Hakimi from Real Madrid ‘I restored hope to 500 households in Kwara’ – Corps member Ryanair’s June passenger numbers show sign of improvement despite sharp drop Wolves flying high as ‘Nuno’ prepares for 150th game Nigeria, Indonesia to review, refocus military ties Valencia’s Rodrigo suffers knee injury Ford sales down 33 percent in second quarter United States Supreme Court takes up Trump bid to withhold parts of Russia report Buhari approves renewal of appointment of 12 non-career Ambassadors Young people aged 20 to 40 driving COVID-19 transmission – NCDC COVID-19: Union donates cash to aged, widows, disables, others in Kwara Insecurity: Gombe College hires vigilante men to watch over institution Industrial output in Italy down nearly 22 pct in Q2 EFCC arraigns ex-Scholarship Board boss over alleged N127m fraud Food Security: Gov. Bagudu reiterates commitment to sustain support to farmers  Buhari salutes renowned educationist, Alex Ajayi, at 90 Child abuse: OYSG records 17 cases in 4 months – Govt NNPC allays fears of possible fire on dripping Lagos pipeline Kenyan cybercafes boom as COVID-19 increases digitization of services Egypt receives 313 tourists from Switzerland, Belarus amid flight resumption Kaduna Govt to generate data on rape from 2015 to date Adelami blames APC leadership for exit of Ondo Deputy Governor NUJ Nasarawa council gets new leadeship Expert seeks inclusion of statisticians in coronavirus contact tracing Clergy, 1 other in court for allegedly sending threatening text messages Nasarawa Govt tackles pension  Dhabeji SEZ under CPEC to open new vistas of prosperity for Pakistan COAS inaugurates Nigerian Army Barracks in Epe German companies reduce vocational training during COVID-19 crisis Armed man arrested near Canadian governor general residence