Connect with us

Judiciary

Supreme Court strikes out Nwosu’s appeal against Ihedioha’s Election

Published

on

Supreme Court strikes out Nwosu’s appeal against Ihedioha’s Election

The Supreme Court on Tuesday struck out


the appeal against the election of Imo State Governor, Emeka Ihedioha filed by Uche Nwosu the governorship candidate of the Action Alliance (AA) in the March 2019 election.

Tanko Mohammad, the Chief Justice of Nigeria (CJN) and presiding Justice of a seven member panel sitting struck out the appeal following an oral application for withdrawal by counsel to the appeallant, Solomon Umoh SAN.

Nwosu and his party, AA are among three candidates seeking the nullification of Ihedioha’s election on allegations of malpractices and non compliance with the electoral laws during the March 9 governorship election in Imo State.

However, when the matter was called, lawyer to the appellants, Chief Solomon Umoh informed the court that based on the decision of the apex court delivered on December 20, 2019 that his client was not qualified to participate in the March 9 governorship election in Imo State, he advised them that the appeal be withdrawn.

Umoh accordingly moved for the withdrawal of the appeal.

When the withdrawal of appeal was no opposed by respondents in the appeal, the presiding Justice, accordingly ruled, “Appeal having been withdrawn is hereby struck out”.

NAN reports that on Nov. 19, 2019, the Court of Appeal affirmed the victory of Ihedioha as the governor of Imo.

A five-member panel of the court led by Justice Oyebisi Omoleye delivered the judgment on Tuesday following the appeals filed by the Action Alliance, All Progressive Grand Alliance and the All Progressives Congress challenging the election of the governor.

The appellants had argued that Ihedioha did not obtain the constitutionally required one-quarter of the votes cast in at least two-thirds of the 27 local government areas of the state, as provided under Section 179 of the Constitution.

The appellants, therefore, asked the court to set aside the decision of the election petition tribunal and declare them the winner of the election or in the alternative order a rerun.

The three appeals filed against the judgment of the Imo State Governorship Election Petition Tribunal, which upheld the election of Ihedioha, include that of the All Progressive Grand Alliance (APGA) and its candidate, Ifeanyi Ararume; Action Alliance (AA) and its candidate, Uche Nwosu and that of the All Progressive Congress (APC) and its candidate, Hope Uzodinma.

The different appellants asked the Court of Appeal to void the election of Mr Ihedioha on grounds that he did not obtain the constitutional one-quarter of the votes in at least two-thirds of the 27 local government areas of the state, in line with Section 179 of the Constitution.

In their various submissions by their counsel, they asked the court to set aside the decision of the tribunal and declare them the winner of the March 9 governorship election or in the alternative order the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) to conduct a fresh election into the office of Governor of Imo State.

The three-member panel of the tribunal had in a unanimous decision delivered on September 21 held that Mr Ihedioha was lawfully declared the winner of the governorship election by INEC.

The panel led by Justice Malami Dongondaji had in the judgment dismissed Messrs Ararume, Nwosu and Uzodinma’s petitions for lacking in merit on the grounds that they failed to prove the allegations made in their petitions.

Apart from claims that Mr Ihedioha did not obtain the constitutional one-quarter of the votes in at least two-thirds of the 27 local government areas of the state, in line with the provisions of the law, the petitioners had also alleged substantial non-compliance with the Electoral Act and Guidelines, including other irregularities.

But the tribunal in its judgment held that the case of the petitioners was unmeritorious because they failed to call relevant witnesses and that evidence of witnesses called were based on hearsay.

The tribunal, in addition, rejected documents tendered by the petitioners in support of their claims on the grounds that those who led evidence in the documents were not the makers of the documents.

In his appeal, Mr Ararume urged the appellate court to upturn the decision of the tribunal on the grounds that the lower court erred in law when it arrived at the decision that his case and that of his party lacked merit and accordingly dismissed it.

The appeal which was predicated on 22 grounds was argued by his lead lawyer, Awa Kalu, while that of Mr Nwosu and AA, was argued by Niyi Akintola.

That of Mr Uzodinma and APC was argued by Damian Dodo.

They all urged the panel to allow the appeal and grant all the relief sought by the appellants.

However, lead counsel Ihedioha and the Peoples Democratic Party, Onyechi Ikpeazu and K.C.O. Jenna respectively urged the court to dismiss the appeals for being incompetent and lacking in merit.

The respondents submitted that the appeal of the AA and Mr Nwosu in particular constitute a waste of precious time of the court since the Supreme Court, in a judgment delivered on Oct. 22, had already struck out the name of Uche Nwosu as the candidate of the AA in the March 9 governorship election in Imo State.

The respondents also claimed that the appeal of Mr Nwosu lacked merit going by a recent judgment of the Court of Appeal which nullified the candidacy of Nwosu in the governorship election.

NAN reports that  the court began hearing with the appeal of Nwosu of AA but later upheld the preliminary objection by the PDP and Governor Ihedioha that the appeal was faulty.

According to the court, it ought to ordinarily dismiss the appeal but in line with the Supreme Court’s guidelines, it decided to go ahead and determine the appeal.

After listening to and resolving all the issues raised by Mr Nwosu and the Action Alliance against the PDP, Justice Omoleye ordered him to pay N500,000.

Determining the appeal filed by Mr Uzodinma and the APC, the court held that the tribunal had looked at the evidence loophole placed before it and that it is settled law that hearsay evidence is not admissible in court.

Consequently, issues 1,2,3 and 4 were resolved against Mr Uzodinma and the APC.

On issue three which bordered on the dismissal of documents, the appeal court resolved it in favour of Mr Uzodinma.

The court said the tribunal went out of its jurisdiction to resolve the issues but that notwithstanding, the appeal was lacking in merit and was, therefore, dismissed.

Consequently, a cost of N500,000 was awarded against the appellants.

However, a member of the panel, in a dissenting judgment, rejected the cross-appeal filed by the governor and ordered him to pay N1 million to Uzodinma and his party.

The court also dismissed the appeal filed by Ararume and APGA and equally awarded a cost of N500,000 against the appellants.

Edited by: Sadiya Hamza

Sadiya Hamza: is a graduate and a professionally trained journalist, with experience in national news reporting/editing and verification at the News Agency of Nigeria. NNN is a Nigerian online news portal that publishes breaking news in Nigeria, and across the world. Our journalists are honest, fair, accurate, thorough and courageous in gathering, reporting and interpreting news in the best interest of the public, because truth is the cornerstone of journalism and they strive diligently to ascertain the truth in every news report. Contact: editor[at]nnn.com.ng

NYSC strengthens partnership with research institute INEC fixes all pending by-elections for Oct. 31 Auno: Borno Govt resettles 560 displaced families OYSG approves promotion, gratuity for 97 civil servants dismissed in 2012 Economic Sustainability Plan: Association urges FG to engage private sector Sanwo-Olu Listens, gives succour to 50 vulnerable Lagosians Osun landlords groan over alleged “outrageous” Land Use charges EFCC arrests 3 corps members, 19 undergraduates for alleged internet fraud in Ibadan NCPC boss urges Southern Kaduna people to remain calm, hopeful Stakeholders differ on use of safety tunnels, fumigation in fight against COVID-19 Congestion: Maritime agencies working toward 24-hour port services — Jamoh Abia govt. to reabsorb sacked 5,853 teachers Insurgency: NAF assures Borno of unrelenting security effort ESUT holds retreat for new administrators Edo COVID-19 death toll hits 100 — Commissioner Niger Govt. inaugurates 30-man economic advisory committee Court restrains Edo govt from publishing defamatory materials against Okunbo, Oshiomhole CIIN lauds FG’s approval of African Trade Insurance Agency Lagos State Procurement Agency (Amendment) Bill 2020 scales 2nd reading Kwara speaker calls for improved security in border communities Poultry farmers seek FG, Oyo govt.’s intervention to save industry   Monarchs task Lagos State Govt on provision of infrastructure  Nigeria disability data bank takes off in FCT CACOVID: Gov. Bagudu warns against diversion of food palliative Minister inaugurates committee on implementation of N75bn youth fund PDP swears in Enugu State executives  NJC approves appointment of 6 new High Court Judges for Kano NSE market indices drop further 0.58% Man, 44, docked over alleged cheating of woman of N75,000 Assault: Police dismiss Inspector in Osun NLC seeks youth inclusion in political, institutional decision-making Lagos Assembly to amend Anti-Cultism Law, includes punishment for cultist’s parent You have no seats to occupy in Edo Assembly, Speaker tells 14 members-elect Private sector key to successful campaign against COVID-19 – AbdulRazaq Stamp Duty: FG to support states to recover backlog AKK gas pipeline project will revive construction industry — Expert Fatokun joins Kwara United from Sunshine Stars COVID-19: Trade office calls for strategic policy on compliance, trade interventions COVID-19 Lockdown: Lagos Govt. introduces educational programme to aid learning Casual workers docked over alleged N20,000 theft Former Super Eagles goalkeeper close to joining Kwara United Ondo poll: Group declares support for Akeredolu’s re-election 2020 wet season: IFAD, FGN-VCDP distribute agro-inputs in Anambra FG to domesticate Nanotechnology to enhance socioeconomic growth — Onu Ogun Traffic Corps arrests drivers of unlatched containerised trucks LASG inaugurates Oshodi-Abule Egba BRT lane Driver accused of attempting to kidnap 13 passengers remanded in Oyo Bishops Forum calls for fortification of security in Southern Kaduna Kano Court remands man for alleged murder Kwara govt pledges continued support to sports