Connect with us

Judiciary

Supreme Court strikes out suit against Virtual hearing

Published

on

Supreme Court strikes out suit against Virtual hearing

The Supreme Court on Tuesday struck out two suits by Lagos and Ekiti Governments challenging the validity and constitutionality of the Virtual Court Sittings procedure.


A seven man panel presided by Justice Bode Rhodes-Vivour struck out the suits after they were withdrawn by the plaintiffs.

The first suit with number: /260/2020 filed by the Attorney General of Lagos State has the Minister of Justice and the Attorney General of the Federation and the National Assembly as the 1st and 2nd defendants respectively.

The Lagos state government in the suit prayed the Supreme Court to determine whether having regard to Section 36(1), (3) and (4) of the 1999 Constitution (as amended) use of technology by remote hearings of any kind, whether by Zoom, Microsoft Teams, WhatsApp, Skype or any other audio visual or video-conference platform by the Lagos State High Court or any other Courts in Nigeria in aid of hearing and determination of cases are constitutional.

However, when the matter came up, Lagos State Attorney-General, Mr Moyosore Onigbanjo SAN, having taken hint from the apex court that the suit was speculative and preemptive withdrew the suit.

Following its withdrawal, the apex court in a unanimous decision struck it out.

However, Justice Rhodes-Vivour in his ruling held that, “As of today virtual sitting is not unconstitutional”.

“This suit is speculative and having been withdrawn, it is struck out”, he said.

The court also struck out a similar suit marked, ‘’/261/2020’’ filed by the Attorney General of Ekiti state against the AGF, shortly after the suit was withdrawn.

Just like his Lagos counterpart, the Ekiti State AG, Mr Wale Fapounda withdrew his suit after taking the hint that the suit was preemptive.

On its part, Ekiti, challenged the constitutionality of the directive of the Minister of Justice and the Attorney General of the Federation (AGF), Abubakar Malami (SAN) to the Head of Courts at federal and state levels to adopt Virtual Court Sittings in courts.

Fapohunda, in the suit had asked the apex court to issue an order to annul the directive for the adoption of the Virtual or Remote Court sittings for being inconsistent with Section 1(3), 4(6), 5(2), 6(2), 36(3) and (4), 272 and 274 of the 1999 Constitution.

Ekiti State further wants the Supreme Court to determine whether the AGF’s guidelines are not a derogation from the legislative, executive and judicial law-making, law execution and adjudicatory rules making powers exclusively vested in states of the federation in respect of states courts, by virtue of Sections 1(3), 4(6), 5(2), 6(2), 272 and 272 and 274 of the Constitution.

He also prayed the apex court to decide whether Lagos and Ogun state having adopted virtual court hearings pursuant to the lockdown, the three arms of Government in Ekiti State are bound to conduct their legislative, executive and judicial functions pertaining to adjudication in state courts in compliance with the directive upon which the National Judicial Council formulated the provisions of Articles E(1) to E(13) of its Guidelines (issued on May 7, 2020).

Edited By: Sadiya Hamza (NAN)

Ebere Agozie: is a graduate and a professionally trained journalist, with experience in national news reporting/editing and verification at the News Agency of Nigeria. NNN is a Nigerian online news portal that publishes breaking news in Nigeria, and across the world. Our journalists are honest, fair, accurate, thorough and courageous in gathering, reporting and interpreting news in the best interest of the public, because truth is the cornerstone of journalism and they strive diligently to ascertain the truth in every news report. Contact: editor[at]nnn.com.ng

Credible election in Edo will rekindle Nigerians’ hope- Secondus Around 40 migrants drown in shipwreck off Mauritanian coast COVID-19: Again FG extends second phase of eased restrictions by 4 week Gold price continues to fly high, rises to yet another record Female senator donates 21 trailer-load of fertilisers to Adamawa farmers Military allays fear over alleged Al-Qaeda, ISIS inroad to Nigeria NCPC partners CAN, JNI to end Southern Kaduna killings COVID-19: PTF approves gradual reopening of international flights LASG calls for synergy among security agencies COVID-19: Kogi Govt fumigates schools ahead of resumption on Aug. 10 Gov Ikpeazu calls for Federal Secretariat in Abia Asaba Airport to resume operation soon – Delta SSG APC appoints acting state chairman in Akwa Ibom NCC tasks ICT reporters to work in synergy with Commission COVID-19: Coy launches `BackToWork’ safety module for businesses, organisations Boat mishap claims 9 lives in Sokoto   Bayelsa host communities urge FG, Shell to ignore alleged 21 days ultimatum Nasarawa Govt. vows to fish out killers of veteran journalist COVID-19: BEDC donates 100 motoriised hand washing machines to states, others Potato prices crash in Kano Gov. Oyetola launches N100m post COVID-19 Economic Intervention Programme Plateau varsity management, staff undergo COVID-19 test NELMCO saves FG N91bn from PHCN liabilities – MD Minister commends Buhari for support on fight against rape, violence against women Flood: NEMA stakeholders evacuate refuse on Jos waterways Court awards N1m damages against EKEDC for disconnecting consumer over former occupant’s unpaid bills Mobile Payment Operators elect Alabraba as new association chairman We’ll support nutritional activities in Nasarawa – Assembly Speaker Shippers Council donates hospital equipment, relief materials to hospital, orphanage in Jos Man to die by hanging for killing fellow herdsman in Ekiti School resumption: Zamfara Govt. begins fumigation of 193 secondary schools Budgetary pressure: Capital market stakeholders seek alternative funding for infrastructure development I-G Adamu threatens to N10bn damages suit against Sahara Reporters if… Nigeria stock market advances by N26bn Insecurity: Buhari calls for synergy among security agencies heads Gov Sule promises justice for family of 3-month-old baby raped in Nasarawa Troops deactivate 25 illegal refineries, impound 342,000 ltrs of AGO in South-South COVID-19: CACOVID targets 10m people with palliatives worth N23bn PenCom initiates process to review 2014 Pension Reform Act North West farmers back to work amid troops operations –DHQ AFAN wants FG to establish commodity board to mop-up excess farm produce Kwara govt. pledges to reposition Aviation College, inaugurates visitation panel Ekiti court dissolves 11-year-old marriage on grounds of threats to life, others Enugu state community laments lack of government presence Lagos, stakeholders seek sustained implementation of breastfeeding policy Gender activist advocates enforcement of policies protecting girls, women’s rights Draft document on protecting telecoms infrastructure awaits presidential assent — Pantami Gov. Oyetola inaugurates committee against gender violence Group seeks meritocracy for appointment of UI VC C’River water board dismisses 6 for non performance