The Presidential Election Petition Tribunal sitting in Abuja, on Tuesday upheld president Muhammadu Buhari’s victory in the Feb. 23 general election.
Nigeria News Agency reports that the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) and its presidential candidate, Atiku Abubakar had filed a joint petition that challenged the president’s victory in the election.
Delivering judgment, Justice Mohammed Garba, Chairman of the five-man tribunal held that the petitioners failed to discharge the burden of proof expected of them.
reports the judgment hinged on five issues raised by the petition which was whether Buhari was qualify to contest the election.
The petitioners also prayed that tribunal to decide whether the alleged false information by the president on his educational qualification amounted to perjury.
They further invited the tribunal to decide whether the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) did not transmit the results of the election electronically via its central server.
The petitioners asked the court to decide whether the respondents did not benefit from widespread rigging, over voting, violence intimidation perpetrated by their agents and security forces deployed to oversee the conduct of the election.
Lastly, the petitioners had urged the tribunal to hold that the president did not secure majority lawful votes.
Garba said the petitioners were unable to satisfactorily provide evidence to substantially prove the allegations contained in the issues canvassed.
“The tribunal is left without options to grant any of the prayers because we are not magicians to decipher exactly what to do in the circumstance other than to dismiss the petition,’’ he said.
On the alleged non-qualification of the president to contest the election, Garba said Buhari was duly screened and certified to contest the election by INEC as he met the requirement and guidelines set by the electoral body.
On the allegation of false information on his education qualification, the chairman of the panel held that evidence placed before the court showed that Buhari obtained Secondary School Certificate.
The judge also held that the president enlisted in the country military and steadily rose to the rank of Major General.
He said the Constitution and the Electoral Act 2010 had also placed powers on the electoral body to decide alternative qualification for those aspiring to contest elective positions in the country.
On whether or not the results of the general election were transmitted electronically to INEC’s central server, Garba said no existing law had approved the use of such technology in the country electoral process, adding that the laws only mandated the manual collation of election results.
Deciding on the allegation of widespread malpractices and violence disruption of the election, Garba held that the petitioners failed to bring specific evidence to substantiate those claims.
He said negligible numbers of the 62 witnesses called by the petitioners highlighted issues that bordered on electoral fraud.
Garba said allegations of electoral made by the petitioners were criminal in nature and therefore required to be proved beyond reasonable doubts.
The judge also held that neither the president nor the All Progressive Congress (APC) could be held to account for the alleged ballot box snatches and other cases of violence allegedly carried out by individuals.
“The respondents cannot be held culpable for the alleged overzealousness of some security forces accused to have unleashed terror on voters and supporters of the petitioners during the election.
“Also, it is expected that the petitioners should have brought witnesses who were at the spot in all of the polling unit where these alleged malpractices and violence were committed.
“In the circumstance, the petition lacks depth as the petitioners were unable to discharge the burden of proof on all the issues before us.
“The petition is therefore dismissed for lack of competence. All parties to bear their costs,’’ Garba said.
reports that the tribunal earlier disposed of seven interlocutory applications bordering on some contending issues raised by the parties.
Giving ruling on a motion filed by the president challenging Abubakar’s citizenship, Garba held that Buhari ought to have approached the court with a cross appeal on the matter.
He therefore, dismissed the motion for lacking in merit.
reports that Buhari was declared the winner of the election after scoring 15,191,847 votes as against Atiku’s 11, 262,978 votes.
Chief Wole Olanipekun, SAN, Counsel for Buhari, described the petition as a sham as it lacked substance and merit.
“I have handled a few electoral petition cases, this is one petition that yarns for help, for assistance and for evidence but could not get any.
“Apart from the hype the matter has generated, there is nothing in law to support the allegations before the tribunal, Olanipekun said.
On the qualification of the president, Olanipekun said Section 131 (b) had settled that matter.
“I make bold to say that the Constitution and case laws had not compelled the candidates of the election to tendered certificates or attached same to INEC form before submission.
“The laws only mandate any person contesting election in the country to have gone to school up to Secondary School level,’’ he said.
On the issue of election results transmission by electronic means, the counsel said the use of such technology must be provided for in the Electoral Act.
“The allegation on the management of server by INEC is vague. Where is the server? This is a million dollar question that the petitioners could not substantiate.
“This petition is liable to be dismissed with a considerable cost’’, Olanipekun said.
On his part, Mr Lateef Fagbemi, SAN, Counsel for All Progressive Congress (APC) said he could not help but take the liberty to align himself with the submissions made Olanipekun.
“My Lords it is disheartening to see that this petition still remains watery at this stage.
“The petition made allegations they could not proof. We have done a table showing how the petitioners have proven the case so far.
“The election took place in 119,976 Polling Units, 8,901 Wards in 774 Local Government Areas across the country.
“It is sad therefore to see that the petitioners only called 62 witnesses. Out of this figure, only five witnesses gave direct evidence of what happened in polling units on the day of election.
“I feel sad that this matter has been starved of evidence and therefore deserves to be dismissed,’’ Fagbemi said.
Also, Mr Yunus Usman, SAN, Counsel for the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) urged the panel to uphold all of its objections raised against the admissibility of all pieces of documentary and oral evidence led by the petitioners.
Usman submitted that the electoral body conducted the Feb.23 presidential election in total compliance with provisions of the Electoral Act 2010 (as amended).
He also urged the panel to disregard the petitioners’ claims that the results of the election were transmitted electronically to a central server managed by INEC, adding that it was the “greatest lie of the century’’.
He submitted that it was laughable when the petitioners made pleadings that suggested that only the PDP and APC and their candidates contested the election.
Usman prayed the tribunal to take judicial notice of the fact that the Electoral Act 2010 prohibited the transmission of election results electronically.
According to him, the law only provides for manual transmission of election results.
Usman said that all the witnesses presented by the petitioners admitted to the fact that transmission of election results electronically had no placed in the country’s statute books at the moment.
In countering allegations that INEC abandoned its pleadings by not presenting witnesses, the counsel said the commission simply extracted salient pieces of evidence from the petitioners’ pleadings to solidify its defence.
“It would have amounted to wasting the time of the tribunal for us to call witnesses when the petitioners could not discharge the burden of proof on allegations they had made,’’ he said.
Usman thereafter prayed the court to dismiss the petition for lack of merit.
Meanwhile, Dr Livy Uzoukwu, SAN, Counsel for the petitioners urged the tribunal to discountenance the addresses of the respondents, adding that the petitioners had indeed discharged the burden of proof.
He said the tribunal must exercise its powers in good conscience to uphold the petition and return Abubakar as president.
Uzoukwu further said the second respondent (Buhari) was unable to present his Secondary School Certificate before the tribunal in order to rest the allegation.
“My Lords, we pray the panel to judiciously and judicially evaluate our evidence in context of whether we have justified our allegation against Buhari’s certificate or not.
On the issue of server, Uzoukwu said INEC had operated, activated and stored the Feb.23 election results in a centrally controlled server.
reports that the tribunal would have to rule on all pending interlocutory applications filed by parties before delivering judgment on the main appeal.
edited by Sadiya Hamza
- UNICEF, Kano Govt. inaugurate TWG to tackle poverty index
- Lagos Govt seals 309 health facilities in 2019
- Why incest is becoming rampant in Nigeria – Experts
- Don tasks capital market regulators on bills to address unclaimed dividends, beneficiary owners
- Woman leader canvasses more support for women to alleviate poverty
- SEC assures Dantata subscribers of claims settlement
- CBN clarifies position on operation of domiciliary accounts
- Upsurge in incestuous relationships, threat to lineage arrangement – NAN Survey
- Roadside trading: C/River govt begins work on new market
- Police search for parents of rescued 10-year-old girl in Anambra
- NAMA commissions CAT3 ILS in Lagos, Abuja airports
- Cleric tasks Christians on love, forgiveness
- Jigawa SDP flagbearer, Bashir Adamu, joins PDP
- Stakeholders want NAICOM to increase citizens’ awareness on insurance matters
- Explosion: DPR warns against sales of gas in residential areas
- Okowa salutes Elumelu at 55
- Clergy urges Christian faithful not lose hope in prayers
- Annuity contributes about 40 per cent investment to insurance sector – NAICOM
- Corruption bane of public education in Nigeria – Stakeholder
- Colourful Nigerian culture, tradition on display as Army celebrate WASA in Badagry
- Union urges FG to fund research for national development
- Senator seeks cooperation of Ondo community, BEDC over prepaid meters
- Oyo govt. to reintroduce Open-Day in public primary schools
- New Moon: Sultan directs Muslim faithful to look for Rajab 1441AH
- NDIC liquidates 427 institutions — official
- Foundation donates food items to IDPs in Edo
- SEC generated N194.48m from penalties in 2019 — Uduk
- Police arrest serial rapist in Anambra
- MNJTF Force commander visits amphibious units, tasks troops on synergy
- Police arrest driver for raising false alarm on herdsman’s attack
- Sen. Gyang urges colleagues to reject rehabilitation, reintegration of Boko Haram terrorists agency bill
- Abuja residents lament decline in local dialects
- Catholic NGO raises funds to support less privileged, poor in the society
- 37th Ramat Cup: SWAN urges Kwara Govt to host, reward victorious team
- NAICOM commences full digitisation of its operations
- Cleric cautions couples against divorce in marriage
- Cleric decries high rate of divorce among young couples
- Group tasks FG on PWDs access to reproductive health care services
- Association seeks partnership with Delta Govt on waste management
- Ex-CBN director harps on mechanised farming to check rising inflation
- Ogun police deny killing Remo Stars footballer
- NCC boss, others honoured at 2020 GAGE Awards
- In New York, Dabiri-Erewa, others stir Pan-African spirit
- Gov. Mohammad appoints Balewa as Mass Education Boss
- Nigeria’s Anyanacho clinches Tokyo 2020 Olympics ticket
- FRSC Unit Commander, builds, dedicated 100 sitting capacity hall to Corps Marshall
- Awka Devt Union kicks over NBA delay in hearing criminal petition against a lawyer
- Fury annihilates Wilder in heavyweight title rematch
- How troops repelled terrorist attack on Garkida
- Army committed to families of fallen heroes welfare -TRADOC
- Morales’ spectacular strike downs Real Madrid as Hazard limps off injured
- GSSS Pyakasa, Javino Model School win maiden FCT secondary schools cricket softball competition
- Gbajabiamila bags traditional title in Kebbi
- Customs seizes 140 smuggled gas cylinders, 678 fertiliser bags in Katsina
- Long three months ahead for Spurs, Mourinho says
- New signing Braithwaite vows not to wash Barca shirt after Messi embrace
- Van Aanholt thunderbolt against Newcastle gives Palace first win in 2020
- Falana accuses corrupt political elites as fueling religious intolerance
- Borussia Dortmund beat Werder Bremen as Haaland keeps up scoring run
- Sarri complains about VAR confusion
- If you must beg, beg govt not individuals, Emir Sanusi tells beggars
- Long and Armstrong give Saints 2-0 home win over Aston Villa
- Co-operative society advocates ranching as solution to farmers/herders clashes
- Kano Photographer organises ‘walk against drug abuse’
- FG pledges to deliver roads that will stand test of time – Minister
- Burnley beat Bournemouth 3-0 amidst VAR farce
- Abacha Loot: No plan to surrender $100m to Gov. Bagudu – Presidency
- Messi hits four goals as Barca hammer Eibar 5-0
- G. Jesus seals win for Manchester City at Leicester
- Marseille’s 14-game unbeaten streak ends with defeat by Nantes
- Ronaldo equals Serie A record of scoring in 11 consecutive matches
- Ex-commissioner identifies bane of education
- FG committed to making Yauri festival global brand – Minister
- Cleaner Lagos: Group urges Nigerians to imbibe voluntary service culture
- Buhari charges graduates on application of knowledge in dev’t
- Gov. Mohammed tasks traditional leaders on bush burning
- Complaints: CBN recovers over N82m for commercial banks customers in Katsina
- PDP chairman says party better positioned to reclaim Edo
- National Park Service needs more support from stakeholders – C-G
- APC chieftain urges Buhari to ignore calls against Oshiomhole
- EPL: Giroud on target as Chelsea beat Spurs to stay fourth
- LASG reiterates commitment to prioritise welfare of traditional rulers
- NAICOM worry over obsolete insurance laws,wants urgent amendment
- Don’t use God’s name to cajole people into marriage – Cleric
- Rigatta Festival: I have seen potential gold medalists, says Speaker Gbajabiamila
- Fintiri urges traditional rulers to mobilise subjects for self-help projects
- FG restates commitment to preservation, protection of cultural heritage
- Nigeria’s Homefort Energy wins RCCG’s $5,000 Kingdom Hackathon prize
- Solar-powered car inventor advocates promotion of solar technology
- Insurgency: TRADOC Commandant says army focused, ready to deal with challenges
- Ondo PDP elects Alabere as deputy chairman
- Girl-child education: NGO urges KDGS to establish female education agency
- Oyo govt. warns against unauthorised road closure
- Farmer/herder conflicts require real-time, practically-oriented solution – Malami
- Salazar link hit me financially and emotionally, Farah laments
- Adopt new processes to block revenue collection leakages- Anambra Assembly
- Tuchel surprised by PSG players partying after Borussia Dortmund defeat
- Mother, daughter, vulcaniser burnt as tanker explodes in Ogun
- NAF neutralises ISWAP leaders in Borno
- Nigerians should be prepared to pay more for electricity — TCN boss
- FG restates commitment to preservation, protection of Nigeria’s culture
- Declare Kalu’s seat vacant — Abia PDP chieftain
- Kwara monarch rallies support for entrepreneurs
- Ondo guber: I will accept APC panel decision –Kekemeke
- 398 benefit from NYSC free medical outreach in Anambra community–Coordinator
- Loss of family values cause of Nigeria’s security challenges – Pastor Adefarasin
- Nigerians to enjoy hourly train services on Lagos-Ibadan route soon—NRC
- Buhari committed to making Nigeria Africa’s commercial hub – ILDC
- New executive for South West Zone of CAN inaugurated
- Outrage as police vehicle hits, kills woman, injures others in Jigawa
- FRSC records 59 deaths from Lagos, Ogun road crashes in January
- Anambra Govt to deploy drone technology to improve healthcare delivery – Commissioner
- Aso Rock murder: NCWS calls on FG to bring killers to book
- RCCG extends assistance to over 50 widows of policemen in Sokoto
- Adamawa lawmaker trains youths on entrepreneurship, leadership principles
- Kebbi govt. restates commitment to creating more jobs, wealth
- COVID-19: WHO warns of reducing opportunities to contain spread, pledges support for Africa
- Z-SIP: Zamfara disburses N56 million for youth empowerment
- FG, nutrition group to develop roadmap to tackle nutrients’ deficiency
- Buhari mourns first NDA Cadet, Col. Ogbebor
- Home, IDP coordinator appeals for feeding, education assistance
- KDSG strategises to implement inclusive education
- Top-4 finish for Spurs will be incredible, Mourinho says
- Group calls for National Disability Commission
- Kwara beat Bauchi 1-0 to win Ramat Cup in Kano
- KDSG reiterates commitment to quality education for every child
- Commissioner urges police cadets to exhibit good conduct
- Gov. Obaseki flags off countdown to Edo 2020
- Alleged sexual abuse: KDSG prays court to grant her custody of 2 children
- Int’l Mother Language Day: Experts advise parents to teach children indigenous languages
- Zambia suspends collection of blood for HIV survey assessment after resistance from citizens
- Mother Tongue Day: Parents restate commitment to ensure children speak fluently
- Youth Group seeks to collaborate with Police Force on effective policing
- U.S. hails FATF’s decision to keep Iran on terrorism financing blacklist
- Lawmaker disburses N6.25m to 250 indigent students in Badagry
- Uche Nwosu lauds late Sen. Uwajumogu, advises politicians to shun do or die politics
- Group seeks promotion of mother tongue to preserve culture
- Banditry: Kebbi govt. to sustain welfare of soldiers families
- We’re creating enabling environment for investors to thrive in Oyo — Makinde
- FG to create 300, 000 jobs in Plateau through agric scheme
- Forex: CBN injects $292.34million into retail Secondary Market
- ABU Zaria, U.S embassy collaborate on homecoming stage play for Black History Month
- Police arrest 3 notorious kidnappers, rescue victim in Kaduna
- Police kill 2 armed robbery suspects in Abuja
- Kogi Assembly advocates joint security operation to curb spate of kidnapping
- Don urges youths to explore potentials in Forestry for self reliance
- LASUBEB tasks stakeholders on success of school feeding programme
- Liverpool captain Henderson out for three weeks with hamstring injury
- 10,000 people join Greta Thunberg at Hamburg climate protest
- Expert advocates men’s participation in family planning
- Terror finance watchdog re-imposes sanctions on Iran
- Commission summons British Airways CEO, GM over consumer rights violation
- Syria: UN Chief issues urgent $500m humanitiarian appeal
- Gov. Masari allocates 140 hectres for textile industry in Funtua
- Grassroots sport devt: Minister, gov, Amokachi, Yobo, others storm Ibadan for Oyo Unity Cup finals
- Gowon seeks Gov. Mohammad’s support for prayer rally in Bauchi
- 141 hospital staff investigated for giving free medicals to friends
- Osinbajo honours Mimiko at mother’s funeral
- Minister calls for more investments in cloud computing
- U.S. Government supports early grade learning in local languages with Minister of Education and Human Development
- Global watchdog places Iran on terrorism financing blacklist
- U.S. Embassy Burkina Faso Welcomes Three New Nouveaux Horizons (NH) Ambassadors
- Covid-19: ‘Window of opportunity narrowing’ as virus spreads outside China-WHO
- S’Korea, Japan to hold talks next month over trade row
- France shuts down its oldest nuclear power plant
- Osun Traditional Council suspends Oluwo of Iwoland
- IBEDC pleads with customers over TCN-Ayede fire outbreak
- Buhari calls for more patience over border closure
- Anambra govt. initiates measures to check youth restiveness – Commissioner
- FCTA arrests 123 traffic offenders, convicts 110
- Kogi releases N56 m for treatment of Lassa fever patients
- Reduction in violence begins at midnight-Afghan President
- Fayose denies plans to dump PDP
- FG restates commitments to poverty reduction, sustainable development-Minister
- CAN honours slain chairman, declares Jan. 21 annual national day of prayers
- Son of Mexican drug lord extradited to U.S., minister says
- Russia rejects claim of meddling to get US President Trump re-elected
- Sports minister harps on more private sponsorship for basketball clubs
- 13 men remanded in correctional centre over alleged unlawful possession of firearms
- I have more than I needed in life, says Fr. Hickey
- 17 ships discharge petrol, other items at Lagos port – NPA
- Centre for Black Arts tasks Teachers on indegenous languages in schools
- Abia Govt. set to train teachers
- Security: Kwara Govt donates 9 vehicles to Operation Harmony
- AIMS LAUNCHES APPLICATIONS FOR THIRD COHORT OF THE AFRICAN MASTER’S IN MACHINE INTELLIGENCE (AMMI) PROGRAM
- Parties de-registration: DPP challenges INEC in court
- Viral conjunctivitis outbreak hits Angola
- Gov Makinde, Ajimobi pay last respect, as Lekan Are goes home
- Residents uncover suspected kidnappers camp in llorin
- African Development Bank issues call to strengthen fertilizer value chains at Argus Africa Fertilizer Conference
- Ilorin Court grants contractor N5m bail
- Coronavirus Scare: Hundreds to be quarantined in northern Italy
- Sports: Gov. Matawalle dissolves state-owned Football Club
- Fashola Inaugurates Gombe Housing Estate
- Kwara Govt to incorporate cancer screening into PHC
- Mo Abudu becomes grandmother
- Pompeo in Oman for talks with new ruler
- Lagos State Govt. to punish illegal Real Estate business practitioners
- Ekiti Govt. insists on due process over selection of new monarch for Otun Ekiti
- Petroleum Industry Governance Bill absence, hampers investment in Oil, Gas sector