A U.S. rule meant to increase the number of heart transplants for the sickest children has not resulted in improved survival, a new study has found.
The March 2016 change in how organs are allocated gave first priority to children born with significant heart defects, such as when most of the left side is missing.
Those with a kind of pumping deficiency called cardiomyopathy, on the other hand, were in most cases given lower priority – on the theory that their cases were more manageable with medication.
But since the change took effect, physicians have been more likely to seek special exceptions for certain cardiomyopathy patients, bumping them up to top-priority status and partly undoing the intent of the policy, the authors wrote in the American Journal of Transplantation.
Survival rates did not improve among any categories of children waiting for heart transplants, and the rates even got a bit worse for patients with certain kinds of cardiomyopathy, who were not assigned top-priority status.
The study authors did not fault the physicians, who sought exceptions, as they were trying to save the lives of desperately ill children.
But the policy language that allows for the exceptions may be “too loosely worded,” said senior author Brian Feingold, medical director of pediatric heart failure and heart transplantation at UPMC Children’s Hospital of Pittsburg.
“There is no ill intent here. Obviously we have to prioritise, and we have to do it in the best way possible to maximize survival,” Feingold added.
He said it could be hard to predict which children were in greatest need of a transplant, in part because there were few of them overall, encompassing a wide range of complex conditions.
Each year, roughly 50 to 70 children die while waiting for a donor heart, according to the U.S. Organ Procurement & Transplantation Network.
“I would love to have a tool, a calculator that I could plug in various characteristics of a patient’s case and understand with good certainty whether this was a patient who had two weeks to survive, three months to survive, or three years to survive.
“We don’t have that,” he added.
At Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, pediatric cardiologist Matthew O’Connor said he had obtained exceptions as allowed by the policy, acquiring the highest priority on the wait list for the most gravely ill cardiomyopathy patients.
Many such patients can delay the need for a transplant by getting an implanted pump called a ventricular assist device but some smaller children might not be good candidates for the device, leaving a transplant as the best option, said O’Connor, who was not involved with the study.
He agreed with the study authors that better tools are needed to predict survival.
“I think it’s still showing that we are having a difficult time determining who really the sickest patients are in our field,” he said.
The head of the national committee that oversees pediatric heart transplant allocation policy, Dallas-based pediatric heart surgeon Ryan Davies, was not available for comment.
To obtain top-priority status for a heart-transplant candidate who would not otherwise qualify, a physician must demonstrate “using acceptable medical criteria, that a heart candidate has an urgency and potential for benefit comparable to that of other candidates at the requested status,” according to the policy.
Physicians were most likely to obtain exceptions for patients with a form of cardiomyopathy called “dilated,” in which the ventricle is stretched thin and cannot pump as strongly.
Some were younger than one year of age.
In the region of the national organ-transplant system that includes Pennsylvania and New Jersey, patients with dilated cardiomyopathy were significantly more likely to obtain top-priority exceptions after the policy was changed.
From December 2011 to March 2016, two out of 57 candidates in the region obtained that type of exception – a rate of less than 4 per cent.
From March 2016 to Sept. 2018, nine of 32 regional candidates obtained that type of exception, a rate of 28 per cent.
Edited by Fatima Sule/
- Wrongful death trial over ‘Walking Dead’ stuntman begins
- Israeli parliament set to dissolve itself, head into third elections
- House Democrats announce 2 articles of impeachment against Trump
- Nigeria, Brazil strengthen ties to boost economy, counter insecurity
- Gov. Matawalle warns mischief makers
- NJ Ayuk’s book Billions at Play: The Future of African Energy and Doing Deals now available in Spanish
- FMC Yenagoa marks 20th anniversary with free medical outreach for host community
- Anambra: Ojukwu varsity inducts 47 doctors, as Obiasor carts home 12 awards
- NNPC set to take measures to curb oil theft
- Gov. Ishaku tasks state governments on Human Rights promotion
- International Human Rights Day: U.S. Consulate urges empowerment of local leaders empowerment to protect citizens rights
- National security: Air Chief assures best training for NAF personnel
- Abuse: Create platforms for students to rate lecturers anonymously- Gender Activist
- DMO clarifies Nigeria’s external debt
- 35 land grabbing cases pending in Lagos courts – attorney-general
- LSFVCB arrests 30 sellers of pirated films
- Don calls for integration of orature into universities curriculum
- Lagos courts to go digital in 2020 — AG
- Anchor Borrowers:CBN tasks cotton farmers on prompt repayment of agric loans
- ICMPD to train 500 teacher-trainers on mainstreaming trafficking in persons into NCE
- College of Insurance partners international organisations to boost status
- Hate speech: NBC urges FG to promote news literacy, professional journalism
- Improve capacity building in medical image analysis, computer vision- Expert
- Jigawa, Kaduna, Delta tops 2018 states budget transparency – Report
- Swedish envoy urges strategic action, awareness creation against gender-based violence
- N80 bn budget for 23 Kaduna LGAs scales 2nd reading
- Nigeria supports global efforts on elimination of Nuclear weapons
- Yuletide: Stop using fake, substandard tyres to avoid road crashes- Olagunju
- NDLEA destroys 11,669 kg of illicit drugs worth N1.65bn in Nasarawa
- British Council presents development grants to women groups in Adamawa
- UN wants Somali youth to promote human rights protection for stability
- Institute solicits FG’s support to provide detailed survey, soil resources mapping
- Boris Johnson under fire as health survey finds many die in emergency wait
- 4 Brigade Troops arrest 5 for suspected murder, armed robbery
- Russian separatists in Ukraine signal support for peace deal
- Minister expresses concern over human trafficking
- Experts advocate mental health therapy for GBV victims
- Yuletide: Oyeyemi warns transport unions against overloading, speeding
- Israel reaffirms commitment to partnering Nigeria on agric technology, entrepreneurship devt
- Promote rule of law over self interest, Oyo Speaker urges lawyers
- Berlin declares emergency in climate
- Emir of Karaye lauds NMA over contribution to community health
- Nigeria Immigration Service Deputy CG, Anene, retires
- SWAN commends Gov. Abdulrazaq over baseball park renovation
- Germany working on defense system to protect airports from drones
- Buhari calls for multilateral approach to combat terrorism
- NECO: EFCC arrests vice-principal, 2 others over exam malpractice in Ilorin
- No reprieve for Hungary in EU grilling over rule of law concerns
- Without convergence, single currency will be catastrophic – ECOWAS Commission President
- Forgive me, Fayose begs aggrieved PDP members